I've actually been pretty pleased with Extreme. I am on day 2 of week 2, and am surprised I've stuck with it this long. I have been making a few substitutions of my own: Busch's vegetarian baked beans (whenever the meal plan calls for beans), Slim Fast Optima for the protein shake, playing around with the workout schedules, etc. OH, and chocolate every day - can't live without that!!! (sugar free jello pudding with a dollop of lite cool whip, which is actually quite good) This week I plan to have the whole wheat Lipton rice mixes when the plan calls for brown rice; that is just one thing I can't get around, icky sticky flavorless brown rice...
Yesterday I went on a 3 1/2 hour hike up a mountain (part of the Appalachian Trail), so I am counting that as yesterday's 55 mins. and today's two 35 min. workouts. Tomorrow is a rest day, but I plan to hike another mountain nearby. I also decided that my hike allowed me a chicken breast for dinner, in addition to what the plan called for (1 cup of brown rice and two veggies). So, I am using Extreme as my plan to follow, but with minor tweaks here and there.
Bottom line: I am adding in some extra foods here and there, but I figure that what I am eating each day is within the daily point allotment I am allowed for Weight Watchers, so it's kind of like a combo of the two plans. I've cut out most of the garbage I have been eating for far too long, and exercising on a much better schedule than I've been in a long time, and I did see the 4 lbs. go the first week without feeling hungry or deprived. I'm sorry to hear that people are feeling discouraged, and I agree that the meal plans could include a little more oomph to them - that's why I don't feel guilty about adding a bit here and there to them...as long as what I am adding is not a gazillion cookies and cakes!
