3 Fat Chicks on a Diet Weight Loss Community

3 Fat Chicks on a Diet Weight Loss Community (https://www.3fatchicks.com/forum/)
-   General chatter (https://www.3fatchicks.com/forum/general-chatter-72/)
-   -   Judging other plus size women (https://www.3fatchicks.com/forum/general-chatter/279924-judging-other-plus-size-women.html)

Nikel1979 04-19-2013 08:47 AM

And I'd also like to point out that I offered up a suggestion as to why there might be differences in noticing and/or caring about others appearance. That was ignored to instead make digs at me based on incorrect assumptions.

GlamourGirl827 04-19-2013 09:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wannabeskinny (Post 4712061)
It looks to me like the people who are so proud of wearing pj's and lounge clothing out in public have a whole bunch of excuses.... too many kids, no money, no time, all kinds of ailments etc. Seriously, all the time you take in writing about how many other things you have to worry about, and the number of posts put out by glamourgirl alone, that could have been time well spent in finding a decent pair of pants to wear. Just saying.

Nobody has the market cornered on "tough life" and "important things to do." The conversation has been steered from judging about appearance to judging about lifestyle choices. I live quite a busy a life. I am a mother although why that is relevant to anyone I'll never understand. To take my post completely out of context and make me feel bad about how little money you had didn't shame me in the least, your upbringing wasn't more important than mine just because you claim you had less money than me.

Wow, you must be a pleasant person to be around!:rolleyes:

Its a matter of some people don't care if a shallow person like you thinks poorly of their clothes.

The time issue was about caring to notice what others are wearing.

I've stated multiple times that there are many busy people, moms included, that find time to look nice, but I orginially said that being busy would distract you from noticing what other people were wearing.

But if you actually read all the posts, you would see that I started to see that busy has nothing to do with being judgemental and shallow. Yes, I said shallow. How is that not shallow? Being concerned with the superficial, looks, not what lies beneath. I realize many people on this thread are aware and want to change these judgements. That shows insight. You comment just shows you are just shallow...and an @ss.

That its just who you are.

Refer to my "rhetorical" questions to someone...lol..about what society says about those concerned with other's apperance...

Really, I just can't imagine being you, and being so focused on your appearance and so rude to people that don't give a crap about theirs.

This is why I find myself judging people that think like you, because I can't imagine your line of thinking ever coming from someone that is kind, compassionate or worth getting to know. And I'm not referring to people that have recognized that they think this way and want to change it...I mean like you, who doesn't even get why your post is so pathetic.

I think you missed a big point here. I'm not proud of wearing sweatpants...I don't take pride in anything I wear, other than my scrubs :) ...I'm not like you, I don't base my self worth on my clothes. I am proud to have come from poverty and through hard work am now living an upper middle class life. I'm proud that I spent many years before kids volunteering as an EMT. I'm proud that I run (when not preg!) I'm proud that I am a good mother and wife. I'm proud that I'm a nurse. I'm proud to help people. I'm proud that I'm not shallow enough to think down about someone based on the fact that I saw them wearing PJs in a walmart.

What are you proud of? What do you offer the world besides your daily clothing and condescending jugements?

GlamourGirl827 04-19-2013 09:17 AM

What do we as a society think (judge?) about people who are very concerned with appearance? Does it matter if they are concerned with their own vs concern about other peoples? Does that change how we describe them?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Silverfire (Post 4711827)

that was a rhetorical question right?

No. I mean it. Can you answer the questions and still feel ok with how you think of others?

The people that want to stop thinking like this, obviously have answered these questions, and personally don't like thinking that way. So they move towards change.

GlamourGirl827 04-19-2013 09:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elvislover324 (Post 4712096)
I agree with this, any times that I do notice someone (in a good way or a "bad" way, I'm comparing them to myself to see if *I* measure up).

The comments about busy-ness and children here are a bit eye-raising too. Due to some circumstances in my life, at this time I do not have children or a job. I could go on and on about the judgment I get from people in my family and friends. They think I have all the time in the world (which in a sense I do, I can't deny that) but it doesn't make me available for them and their needs 24/7 without some planning. AND...I can assure you my abundance of time doesn't cause me to spend more time in Walmart or anywhere else checking out underdressed or overdressed or whatever observation I might make. I'm at the store to get my errands and shopping done just like the rest of you. And what I wouldn't give to have my own child in a cart to keep an eye on. But just because I don't, it doesn't mean I'm on a judgment patrol for clothes, cleanliness, whatever.

Some posts on this thread have made a few people comment about feeling bad or insecure knowing others are watching and judging on a constant basis. That makes me really sad. We are here to support each other, not make others feel worse.

Read.

My.

Other.

Posts.

I can see which people are half reading before they post. I went on to say that I had thought that being busy would decrease the time to be noticing others...I went on to say that it seems to be more of a personality issue. People that are way to worried about who's wearing sweatpants, will be like that, busy or not.

People that don't need to concern themselves with critisizing others clothes, will not do it, regardless of how much time they have to people watch in the store.

I cannot understand being so mean as to be annoyed at someone wearing sweatpant or PJs out. So I try to think that there's a "reason" ...a fixable reason...I went to "busy" as my reason...For me, if I accept there is no "reason" ...that means to me, that these people are just cruel...I can't comprehend that kind of cruelness...I don't understand why someone would think that other people should dress better as to not offend them...I need to accept that not everyone thinks how I do. That some people do think that they are important enough that others should dress "better" for them to see, and if somone does wear PJs out, then they are annoying.

I wanted the reason to be "busy" or anything!! Besides a what I see as being just plain mean.

I didn't mean to personally offend you.

And I comepletely agree with the rest of your post. I think you are 100% right.

GlamourGirl827 04-19-2013 09:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nikel1979 (Post 4712118)
And I'd also like to point out that I offered up a suggestion as to why there might be differences in noticing and/or caring about others appearance. That was ignored to instead make digs at me based on incorrect assumptions.

Yeah I'm noticing this as well.

GlamourGirl827 04-19-2013 09:37 AM

I want to re post, which I just said in someone else's reponse, that I wanted to find a "reason" for people that are annoyed at people wearing sweatpants or PJs out. That's why I picked "busy" , "age"...I wanted a reason to excuse what I saw as being mean.

I wanted there to be a fixable reason. Because I don't want to accept that some people are just cruel. I think its cruel (and a little entitled) to think other people should dress to your rules or risk you judging them.

People that say if you go out looking like a mess, then you risk being judged, are wrong! They risk being judged by YOU and people like you...but some of us don't think like you. And you think its normal (human nature) to think poorly about people who are a mess in public.

Some of us feel compassion (why is this person dressed down? Not enough money to buy nicer clothes? Depressed? Maybe they are coming from staying up all night with a sick relative?)

Some of us see and don't judge.

And some of us don't notice.

If you think that its "normal" to poorly judge someone that's a hot mess, maybe you need to realize that not everyone thinks like you and stop justifying your judgement by telling your self that everyone is judges the girl in the PJ pants.

I'm sorry I picked busy, or kids, or age. I wanted there to be a reason, besides just being plain mean. Because I'll tell you. its not nice what you are doing! Getting annoyed at sweatpants...yeah definitely not nice...

sacha 04-19-2013 09:40 AM

Apparently, it is acceptable to consider "improper" clothing as a sign of lacking pride in one's appearance - but it is inacceptable to point at that all of us either were, or currently are, overweight.

I assume that we all had (or currently have) no pride in our appearance, because we were/are fat? Is that correct?

elvislover324 04-19-2013 09:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GlamourGirl827 (Post 4712146)
Read.

My.

Other.

Posts.
.

I read all of your other posts. But thank you.

Roo2 04-19-2013 10:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sacha (Post 4712167)
Apparently, it is acceptable to consider "improper" clothing as a sign of lacking pride in one's appearance - but it is inacceptable to point at that all of us either were, or currently are, overweight.

I assume that we all had (or currently have) no pride in our appearance, because we were/are fat? Is that correct?

Sacha- if someone noticed I was Fat that is a correct observation! Not hurtful or harmful the Truth!! Where the difference would be if they said "Hey Fat ...ss you
Are carrying a wideload you need to where a sign" that is rude!

Making observations are not harmful...if you are afraid of people looking or what people might say then you have to make a judgement call yourself.

Yes my allowing myself to get fat showed a lack of attention and or concern, not afraid to own up to my short comings!

And I refuse to do the cop out even though I took a variety of meds for infertility treatments and steroids for years plus other meds.. that the side effect is increase weight gain and increase appetite....in the end I should have been more vigilant ...instead of living in the land of apathy or denial....that's on me.
Wish maybe someone that was close to me would have called me out on it and told me I was a Hot Mess! Might have initially been PO'd but It may have been enough to rattle my cage.
It was not until I got pre qualified for WLS that my family intervened.
Walked outside to grab mail from yesterday had Peddle Pushers on and Ugg Boots on ....if neighbors gawked at the way I was dressed I would not have been offended...boots were right by the door and just grabbed them:D
I realize I looked ridiculous but I was too lazy to look for shoes that looked approriate:D
Roo2:carrot::carrot::carrot:

stella1609 04-19-2013 10:11 AM

I never made any excuses for wearing yoga pants in public. It's comfortable and convenient! And I have a nice butt :) I have plenty of time to change; I just chose to wear what I like.

Song of Surly 04-19-2013 10:14 AM

Whew.

I don't know if it's fair to say that people who are unforgiving judgers are necessarily jerks. I don't think it is a personality trait that I find pleasant, but everyone has got a few nasty traits.

I think judging is more natural for some people than others. I am a bit of a daydreamer, so when I see a person, I'm usually focused on them just long enough to spark some other thought that may be at least marginally related to them. My boyfriend, who is a more focused individual on his immediate surroundings, REALLY notices people. He's a total people watcher, and he has a judgmental streak. I don't think he means it in a mean way, but he has a very strong self-identity, and he is naturally a person that places things in a certain order in his mind. Being the person that he is, the categories can be very rigidly defined (which can drive me insane). So he sees, and he places the things he sees into whatever category he thinks that thing fits in. I see, and then I think of how that thing reminds me of something else. I don't necessarily feel the need to place it anywhere, except in some very vague way. People do both of these things all day every day from birth (it's how we learn), but I think some minds are a little more orderly, and because of that, they don't place things into large pictures that might create more compassion or understanding. When I was thinking about it, all of the judgmental people I know are very Type A, orderly individuals. That is totally just my experience, but I wonder if it's a connection that makes any sense to anyone else.

I also agree with Nikel that some people are more visual or auditory. I pick up conversations so quickly, and it's really hard for me to ignore them or let them go. So freakin' annoying in a restaraunt.

GlamourGirl827 04-19-2013 10:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sacha (Post 4712167)
Apparently, it is acceptable to consider "improper" clothing as a sign of lacking pride in one's appearance - but it is inacceptable to point at that all of us either were, or currently are, overweight.

I assume that we all had (or currently have) no pride in our appearance, because we were/are fat? Is that correct?

I understand what you were saying. And I think this is a very good point. On this site, we have a variety of reasons why we are over weight, different life situations, different experiences and ways of life. I think we know that for someone being fat, there is so much more to it, and it is not about lack in one's pride as you said. But this is a common judgement in society, that fat people are lazy and have no pride in our appearance...and its a hurtful judgement that I'm sure a lot of us have dealt with...when in reality, its not true.


I would love to hang around and keep reading this thread! I have to head out today. But I will likely check back later. :)

Munchy 04-19-2013 10:22 AM

I don't think pajamas outside are acceptable either, unless you are right outside your house and running out to get your mail/newspaper/take out your trash. I also don't own pajamas that would be remotely appropriate outside of my house, so I ALWAYS need to change before I leave in the morning.

I own yoga pants which I use for lounging around my house. I put pants on when I drop off my daughter to school/grocery shop/run errands, just like I brush my teeth before I leave. If I needed to run to get medicine or go to the doctor, I may just head there in yoga pants. I also pick up my daughter from school wearing my workout gear. If I went home to shower/change, I'd be late every single day.

I wear leggings as pants sometimes, because I work hard for this backside. ;)

I really just wanted to comment in this since it's still going. I have nothing substantial to add...lol.

LockItUp 04-19-2013 10:40 AM

Wore yoga pants last night and thought of you all. :D


It's funny, it seems the thread has become more of a debate on what pants everyone thinks are acceptable to wear in public.

I went to the store yeterday evening (wearing knee length jean shorts and fitted t-shirt, just so you know) and when I got back in the car I realized I hadn't notice what ANYONE was wearing, or what anyone looked like, or what size anyone was. Though that was probably due to the fact that one of my lovely children threw a fit right in the middle of the store, to which I'm sure I was thoroughly judged on my parenting. HA! Can't win!

Nikel1979 04-19-2013 11:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sacha (Post 4712167)
Apparently, it is acceptable to consider "improper" clothing as a sign of lacking pride in one's appearance - but it is inacceptable to point at that all of us either were, or currently are, overweight.

I assume that we all had (or currently have) no pride in our appearance, because we were/are fat? Is that correct?

Pride in appearance is really a tricky thing to me, and it bugs me on a feminist level. It's too tied in to what what society and the media say is appropriate appearance. Even when I spend the time to fix my hair and do my makeup and such, I'm still not going to pass the "pride in appearance" test by many people's standards. This hasn't changed from 97 lbs to 250 lbs. I've never been the type that fits in, no matter how hard I tried. Now I just don't care any more about meeting some ideal appearance. I may be the fat, slow, ridiculous looking runner, but I'm also a happy runner. I have friends that appreciate my ridiculousness, and that matters way more to me than some stranger that's just making assumptions of me based on a miniscule snap shot of my life.

I don't avoid leggings based on any fashion reasons. They don't have pockets, and where am I supposed to put my keys? I don't avoid high heels because I can't walk in them or feel self conscious about my height. I sort of miss heels, but they make me use different muscles which affects my running. I was "in costume" for the princess half marathon, but only as much as I felt I could without getting in the way of function, comfort, and practicality.

Maybe this is related, but I'm also not much for tradition and ceremony. My sister in law is having her baby shower next weekend, and there are all these rules - no kids, no men, everyone has to dress up, formal place settings for the meal, etc. To me, that's just exhausting. I'm super relieved that I'll be out of town running a half marathon and then going to a drag show.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 04:46 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.