15 minutes x 3

You're on Page 2 of 2
Go to
  • I am another that says you should do what you can. I first started exercising using the same principle. I was much bigger than you, but I found that I could pretty easily have 3 sessions of 10 minutes of walking. Even after I lost a good bit of weight and increased my exercising, I found the three short sessions of walking helpful. For one thing, since I walked on my breaks at work, it kept me out of the break room and away from the vending machines.
  • Exercise when you know you'll do it. I have a hard time fitting in 30-40 straight min (unless it's a rainy day) so I do a quick work out in the morning, then one in the evening, and sometimes even one later at night. It all depends on how my day goes.
  • There's some very solid evidence from studies by Standford and Johns Hopkins that says you still get very much benefit from mini sessions of exercise. I say do what you can and work on your personal bests! Don't care where you have to start, as long as you start somewhere.

    Here's a write up on some of those studies. Very encouraging for those who are tight on time and/or can't tolerate much activity at once.

    http://www.tinajuanfitness.info/articles/051705.htm
  • Quote: I say do what you can.

    "They" are always changing their minds. I've pretty much no longer believe anything that says you have to do things a certain way to get the most out of it, food or exercise-wise. Someone once sent me something about how you have to time your fruit, otherwise you're doing it wrong. Give it break! These are pretty much the only things I "believe" any more.

    1. Eat food, not too much, mostly plants. -Michael Pollan.
    2. Eat less, move more.

    Obviously, if you're training to be in peak performance for some athletic endeavor, "move more" isn't enough. But until you're at that point, I think it's all good.
    I agree with this entire post! I really think all this change in theory is related to the business side of weight loss, selling foods, products, equipment and so on.
    At the end of the day, weight/fat loss is as simple as eating healthy foods in reasonable portions + exercise.

    ETA: I get exertion headaches so I cannot exercise at a high intensity for long periods of time. Besides walking, I won't exercise more than about 30 minutes at a time (and that's pushing it, I usually last about 15-20 minutes) and I am still losing at a healthy rate, so a little bit at a time is still effective.
  • 4star - thank you for that link!

    and thank you to EVERYONE who commented - I appreciate your input!!
  • Quote:
    Soooo.... maybe I should just look at exercise as a simple means to "movement is good for you" ~ THAT IS... I shouldn't count on it for weight loss, but rather for fitness.
    This! Someone on these boards once said "I exercise for fitness, I eat well to lose weight." That stuck with me big time. I get my heart rate into cardio level and just go. I exercise to be strong, to have healthy insides and I eat less (and healthily) to lose the weight. It's a different mindset, but when I'm less focused on the weight loss side of exercise and more on the fitness side I notice things from that angle. Things like "Hey! I went an extra 5 minutes or boosted my resistance or did an extra set, etc." I pay more attention to the signs that I'm getting healthier and not just the number on the scale.