This is a very helpful thread. I started counting calories last Monday after thinking "I know what I eat every day, have a pretty good idea what my caloric intake is everyday, and I workout...why am I not losing weight?!" Once I tallied them up, I was wayyyy off.
I am 5'8, 31 years old, and started last Monday at 196.8. I am eating between 1460-1650 calories a day and seeing what happens. I checked this morning (even though I weigh in on Fridays) and my weight was 193.6, so I am hoping this caloric range works for me because it's easy to maintain and I am not starving on it.