Quote:
Originally Posted by JJTx
I'm not going to speak for anyone else but myself - it's not that simple. Just because you don't need/value/want a monthly thread, doesn't mean that some of us don't, that they don't have value, or that it should be dictated that we give them up. Most people (at least in ours) post both in the monthly thread and the daily chat, myself included. Honestly what I post in each is different, because I was made to feel very uncomfortable from early on sharing any advice or anything more than superficial. To the point I almost left 3FC - guess who gave me the support to stay? My Summer 2014 starters.
The current effort to "whitewash" all the former monthly/seasonal threads, quite frankly, isn't sitting well with me either. The October 2013 group has kept their identity for almost 2 years. They didn't all start in October, but they have come together, stayed together, and support each other. They also support and advise the rest of us.
So how far should we take it? Get rid of everything but the Daily Chat threads? No more 50+, rebooters, over 100 pounds to lose, less than 20 pounds, maintainers, what did you eat, alternatives (actually this one should stay, there's already a lot of confusing focus and info about alternatives mixed in).
Quote:
Originally Posted by Wahoofan
I deeply hope that my questioning the monthly threads isn't being taken negatively. My only motivation in doing so is the value of the greater community.
I'm not an admin and my opinion is worth no more than that of anyone else. Lately I've felt like the vibrancy of this community has diminished a bit from what it used to be and the sheer number of monthly threads when I opened today stood out as a possible reason.
So as a close to one year on IP I am just going to quickly mention on thing about the Daily and Other threads...I am very very partial to my 2014 thread and we have certainly consolidated and dwindled over the course of a year, but there are 4 or 5 rock solid posters there that I have come to rely on ...we are all in the same boat. It feels very comfortable there for me. I do also post in the daily chat as often as I can, but its a different vibe for me from my 2014 group. I think there is a place for everyone in more than one spot....Personally for me if the 2014 became part of the daily only, I would probably lose interest....Those are my girls from the beginning and we have a special bond and are at the same place on program...
All I am saying is yes there are a lot of threads, but you only need to search out the ones that work for you and ignore the rest....

just my 2cents and I know it aint worth much

SO off to our college whirlwind tour today. Was up nice and early to have my 2 coffee's so that my bathroom routine is not disturbed

those who suffered from the big C on this program will know it makes sense to go the extra mile when you have a routine LOL.. I have all my IP snacks ready to go for the car. Have an extra restricted with me because I am not sure I am going to be able to make a shake so easy... We will be stopping for lunch and dinner. We are seeing Lycoming, Lock Haven and Penn State....Lots of walking today too, just hope the weather clears up a bit.
WI should have been today but instead it will be tomorrow after lunch, I am sure that will reek havoc with the number on the scale and since this will probably be my maintain week, Ugh! Anyway I have to think this week it is just a number on the clinic scale and my Aria scale had me exactly the same as last week this AM so I will take that!