I don't know where Ilene is now, but I bet we know where she'll be at 8pm I'll be there just to see Bo, then I'm changing channels

Loved Bo and Carrie! But I'm not that big of a fan of Vonzell. I have to agree with Simon, I thought she was pitchy in both songs. But I always think she's a little off key. I'm not into the kiss blowing, either, lol. But I'd tak that over someone elses smug behavior any day! And smug seems to be the word tonight

Hi Suzanne, I'm here and yes I was in front of the tube at 8PM sharp... My favs this week in order were: Bo, Carrie, Vonzell, Anthony and ya know what's his name ...

Both of Bo's songs were spot on I thought he sang very well...
Carrie was stiff in the second song, she can be when she feels out of her element...
Vonzell, who is usually my favorite didn't do well tonight...I agree Suzanne the kiss blowing is a bit much...
Anthony I don't even find he has any beat
can't stand the smug ...

Well I watched - Bo is, and will always be, my fave - he has been from day one - I don't care for Carrie's type of music, but she can sing, and she is adorable - I don't like Vonzell - Anthony is cute but he is pitchy - and well is just his total self, as usual

I have a feeling that Anthony will be leaving tomorrow

Sure do wish would leave instead

Ok...I am going to rant here...I have a huge problems with one of last nights performers... and I'll get to in just one second so please excuse my

Anthony - His first song "Poision Ivy" literally had me feeling uncomfortable It was all over the place, and I really couldn't understand a word he was saying. His second song "Incomplete" I didn't even really realize what song it was until he got to the Chorus.... I give him an A- for effort, and D+ in everything else. He picked the wrong songs for him, and he could have showcased his vocals a little more.


Scott - I thought his first performance of "On Broadway" was a great choice for him..but is it me or does anyone else here think he sounds like Aaron Neville? And then when he came out and Did Brian McKnight's "Everythime you go away", I thought to myself "Yeah it was good", but I didn't like it all that much. I think he played it safe, and I am sorry to say He'll be here next week. Although he did sort of get too confident for my liking....


Vonzell - OH MY...where do I start with her..Her first song was a DISASTER!!
She was all over the place vocally, and yet again for her just like Anthony I felt uncomfortable for her because she just wasn't in control. Now is not the time for her to playing around, and letting loose as she said, because one mistake and you're going home. I didn't really care for her song "Treat me Nice". Which leads me to her next song "When you tell me that you love me" as soon as she came out with that I was

First and foremost..by her doing the "American Idol Song" It made her look really Egotistical and Pompus...it was almost like she came out all "I am the next American Idol, so I am going to do this song" but again I feel it was a huge mistake..My Fiance said the same thing it made her look really stuck on herself. And I agree the little kisses blown, and what not...please woman get off of your

Bo - "Yo Man it's like this" He is the man!!! He is the Dog Pound!!!
His songs were perfect for him, "Stand By Me" was Classic, and for the first time ever in all 4 seasons of watching AI faithfully, when he came out with "Heaven" By the Los Lonley Boys I found myself really getting into the song, bopping my head along to the song..you know just really getting into it. Way to go Bo!!

Carrie Carrie Carrie Carrie....WOW all I have to say is WOW...She did "Trouble" Another Elivs Prestley song, and she nailed it. She was in control of her voice, and lyrics at all times, you could clearly hear her, and she didn't turn it into a "Gospel" sounding song like Vonzell did. She was Amazing!!! Then "Bless the Broken Road" WOW I got goosebumps..and that was amazing..

My VOTE would have to be Carrie...she is consistent week after week, and she reminds me alot of Kelly Clarkson but I do think Carrie's Vocals are better than what Kelly's were on the first season.

This Week...who goes home.. I am sad to say but I think it's Anthony

Then Scott
Then Vonzell
Then I think it will be a tough call between Bo & Carrie....

Thanks for reading my post..and this is Irishgirl...out

I kept trying to call for Carrie but I couldn't get through. That HAS to be a good sign. I haven't been impressed with Vonzell lately, she is getting boring, all her songs are the same. Bo did great last night, as did Carrie. actually didn't do too bad on the 1st song, but he is so smug "Simon, you said I was going home..." I wish he would just shut his pie-hole!! Anthony didn't do anything for me, but he wasn't horrible.

Oh, and I tried to goto the "Vote for the Worst" site this morning and it appears to not be working right now Serves that kid right

GOODBYE VONZEL...GO HOME ALREADY!

I THOUGHT HER SONGS WERE TERRIBLE, PITCHY AND SHE SEEMS TO HOLLER AT EVERY ENDING...YUCK!

Bo was fabulous, Carrie was okay, Scott (unfortunately) probably saved his butt and Anthony was just there.

I had a hard time getting through to vote for Bo. That is a good sign though. Means lots of others were voting also.

I thought the show was really good last night. I, too, am ready for rolling-pin-man to GO HOME!! Ich.

I think it will either be Anthony or Vonzell this week, though, unfortunately.

I really like Vonzell, kisses and all. I think she's a good performer!

Bo and Carrie will be in the top two--at least they'd BETTER!! (I don't vote, so I really can't say that )

I text message each week, so my votes get thru Bo is my rocker. I was surprised that even my mom likes him

I don't like country music and that is all Carrie is - but she is a doll and seems to have a very sweet personality.

It's a tough call - I hope Bo wins, but it wouldn't upset me if Carrie did. Just as long as Bo is standing next to her like Justin and Kelly

This competition is getting to me. Last night I dreamed that I was wandering the streets in Greece, looking in windows for Constantine

Tonight will be very interesting. Is anyone going to watch the ABC Primetime special on Idol scandals?