I haven't done CALP exactly, though I know a lot of people have -- I did the Atkins Induction and then switched to CAD (the ancient CALP!) because I just couldn't stand preparing carbs for my family and not being able to eat any! I really like the flexibility and the idea that you can hang on for those carbs during your Reward Meal hour ... But I will say that for most people I imagine Atkins will move the weight off faster. The last time I did this, I lost about 11 pounds on Atkins, then anywhere from 1/2-3 pounds a week on CAD. This time (I started mid-June), I lost about 10 pounds on Atkins, and since then I've sort of just hovered ... I'm sorry to say I may have to go back on Induction to get that scale moving again. I may have several things working against me here: for one, I'm about 5 years older this time; for another, I did go off the plan for one day which set me back; and, since I'm not vigilant about balancing that Reward Meal, maybe it's just not doing it for me this time around.
I suggest you may want to try CALP, and if it doesn't seem to work for you, go back to Atkins.
Good luck -
Pen
|