Yeah, I was just reading the thread. Some of the reasons for believing it's fake are making me laugh out loud.
Most of the weddings that I photograph where there is also a videographer, the groom and the minister are mic'd for the video. Also the videogs I tend to work with are pretty high end (usually there are 2 or more cameras present) and the production quality is outstanding.
So "the video isn't bad enough to be real" comments are kind of cracking me up.
Like I said, given all the weddings I've photographed, I'd tend to believe this is true more than not. Even if *this* isn't true, I'd be willing to believe it has happened before to more than one bride.
.