American Idol

You're on Page 6 of 16
Go to
  • Quote: ended on David Archuleta's performance. He is so cute, I just wanna pinch his cheeks and put him in my pocket!
    That's exactly what my friend and I said when we talked about the show today. He's a cute little thing. It was funny when Ryan said something about people calling in to adopt him. He was all giggly and happy when the judges gave him good comments. I don't think he's quite as good as they're saying, but he's good. His cuteness factor will take him a long way.

    I listened to the radio on the way to work today and people were calling in about the show. So many people were saying they hated Danny Noriega. Now, I know he didn't do as well as he has been doing, but he does have a really good voice. They kept saying things like "He acts so feminine -- I just hate that." It was almost like the Homophobe Patrol was calling in, and they just hated him because it seems like hes gay. Scary. If you're going to hate a contestant, make it because they can't sing or they're dreadfully boring!!
  • I enjoyed the girls tonight. There are 5 that I like. Don't know their names sorry.

    I thought they had an edge over the guys last night.
  • A couple good performances, but overall I don't think the last two nights were really anything special. I thought Castro was the best of the guys and Asia'h the best of the girls. I found last season to be incredibly boring, I'm hoping this one will be better.
  • Overall the girls were better than the boys, but they weren't fantastic. Asia'h was good and I think she'll last. I think Amy Davis will be kicked off for sure -- she's a pretty girl, but that was a boring and horrible performance. And I can't keep all the blondes straight in my head, but I remember the first blonde who was sick gave a pretty crappy performance too. I think that was Kristy Lee, the one who sold her horse to fly to Philly to audition (and I can't figure out why she didn't make a shorter trip to San Diego instead).

    I hope things get a little more exciting! At least the rocker girl is interesting to watch and listen to. I can't decide if I like her, but she doesn't bore me. It was funny that Simon didn't understand the song was supposed to be like that.
  • I really liked the one who sang the Dusty Springfield song "You Don't have to Say you Love Me." I think her name is Ramiel? I also liked Asia and Amanda. I thought Brooke was pretty good. I wish Carly had impressed me more. I like her voice, though.

    Sherry
  • Unfortunately work continues to get in the way of me watching this show. I got home about 9pm or so last night but forgot the show was on. So I guess I will see the results show tonight.
  • I wasn't surprised with who got sent home last night. However I felt so bad for Garrett the way Ryan told him he was going home.
  • I was pleased with the results show. I was surprised that Joanna got sent home over Amanda. I thought Amanda's perfomance was horrible. You couldn't understand what she was saying. She won't make it to the end. I love Brooke. I didn't get to see the end of the girls night, nor did I get to vote. I saw the boys night and voted for David Archuleta. I like his voice a lot. I also like the Micheal Johns. I totally agreed that Garret had to go. Can't wait for next week!
  • Quote: Unfortunately work continues to get in the way of me watching this show. I got home about 9pm or so last night but forgot the show was on. So I guess I will see the results show tonight.
    Since returning to work, I have this same problem. I only work 3 days a week, but wouldn't you know it's Wed. - Fri., and all the good shows (AI, House, Smarter than a 5th Grader) are on those nights. Arrrrgh. Licked it. Picked up my DVR box last weekend.

    Quote: I was pleased with the results show. I was surprised that Joanna got sent home over Amanda. I thought Amanda's perfomance was horrible. You couldn't understand what she was saying. She won't make it to the end. I love Brooke. I didn't get to see the end of the girls night, nor did I get to vote. I saw the boys night and voted for David Archuleta. I like his voice a lot. I also like the Micheal Johns. I totally agreed that Garret had to go. Can't wait for next week!
    I wasn't surprised about Joanna. I kinda thought she MIGHT hold out longer than the first one, but it really was a poor performance. She was one of the three I picked to go, and two of the three I picked went. I've gotten better at figuring out who's gonna be outta there.

    I like David and Michael too. Haven't really decided on the girls, but I like petite little Malubi(sp?), and I LOVE LOVE LOVE Amanda. Go girl! You rock!
  • David Archuleta so good tonight. When he sings he seems so much more older than his years.

    A couple of other good performances.
  • Yep, David Archuleta was good. I think he'll go really far. The judges certainly seem to want him to go far.

    I really liked Jason Castro's performance, though the judges didn't. (He's the guy with the dreads). I liked him last week too, and I think he's my favorite.

    I think Luke Menard and Jason Yeager really need to go. Ugh! Yeager is just one big ball of CHEESE and I just don't understand the appeal of Menard besides his looks. That weird high voice and that strange song he sang -- horrible!!

    I thought Simon was a little mean to the "word nerd" about his crosswords. I'm a word nerd too, so I was much more interested in his story than in drag racing or some of the other ones. Simon seems to forget that there are smart people in America, and that they like other smart people!
  • I agree....Yaeger-bomb needs to go! Luke definitely improved from last week, but may have not done enough to stay. But who knows!!
  • I had a hard time deciding who to vote for. I really like David Archuleta, but I thought Chickezie was really good last night. After the first few I was like Ugh! I'm glad it ended so well. I voted for Archuleta. Can't wait for the girls tonight!
  • Michael Johns really is a bad singer.. but man he's smokin hot. I like David, the young kid. His voice is great. Chikezie is always awesome. He has a great vibe! :-)
  • Is it me, or are the girls just not as good as the guys this year? There were a lot of seriously offkey moments last night. The boys may be boring at times, but they're usually on key, at least.

    I thought Syesha Mercado did really well, but the judges didn't. I didn't like her before because I thought she just yelled all the time, but apparently that's what the judges want her to do (or "power", as Paula calls it).

    The girl who reminds me of a muppet, Brooke White, did well with the Carly Simon song.

    Amanda the rocker was so painfully offkey during the verses that my husband and I couldn't stop cringing. I couldn't figure out why the judges didn't focus on THAT. When you're that offkey in a singing competition, I think that's kind of the big news, more so than the hair or the clothes or the dancing.

    The judges are right about Kady Malloy (the Britney impersonator) -- she's great when she's impersonating Britney or singing opera, but onstage she just falls flat.

    I really REALLY don't understand the Carly Smithson love. She's ok, but not that great.

    Something about Kristy Lee Cook bugs the life out of me.

    I don't really remember anyone else, but I guess that's enough!