Hi again
Of course you have to do what works best for you, but I personally find when I am super strict (on a diet that I am unwilling to deviate from), I always 'fall of the wagon' eventually because I am too strict. If I can add just one or two treats a week, and stop feeling guilty about it (still a problem for me), I find I do much better.
I am totally an 'all or nothing' kind of person, but the closer I get to finding moderation, the better i tend to do on weight loss and maintaining.
I hear you about thin husband who can eat a lot! I'm on weight watchers, so I use my extra points on the weekend when we eat out so I can have at least one 'fun' thing.
The thing I love about this forum is sharing and feeling like there are people out there going through the same thing, so thanks for sharing!