andthrive, you're making everyone jealous here!
I agree, you are probably at a good weight but you're probably just not happy with the way your body looks. Go for the toning as someone suggested. You can do far, far more to get the look you want if you sculpt and work with the muscle. I (a fellow Pittsburgher, by the way!) know because I (at one long-ago point) lost a lot of weight but just looked the same, only smaller. It wasn't until I started working with weights and such that I could really change as I wanted to....well, that is, until the excess fat accumulated to a certain point......
In any case, good for you for wanting to make changes and for addressing your dissatisfaction before it gets out of hand!