just a question

  • Why do the "low carb" recipes seem so high in WW points?
    And do alot of WW members eat "low carb" - if so, how can they stay within points for the day? Thanks in advance.
  • mmmm, could it be the unrestricted amount of fats that are often associated with low carb eating?

    Lets see, my friends were eating bacon as a snack (even turkey bacon has points when you eat five slices at a sitting), adding heavy cream to food adds points.

    Lots of cheese, lots of beef, its all pointy.

    However, I guess you could do a low carb/low fat/high protein thing and stay within a moderate range of points.

    lala
  • Most W/W people do not do a 'low carb' they do a 'lower carb' way of eating. When they eat carbs they eat the whole grains and higher fibers. If you look at the South Beach Diet Phase 2 and beyond that is more of what they are doing.

    Yes the low carb recipes are higher in fats thus making them high points.

    Personally I would not do a low carb but I did reduce my carbs with W/W.
  • Thanks for your input. I think I should do a lower carb/higher protein WW menu. I was looking over my past journals & they are definately leaning towards high carbs.

    Once again, thanks.
  • If you have access to eTools on the Weight Watchers website, you can use the new "PointsPie" to see a sample breakdown of points into protein, carb, and dairy (I think). They have three different "pies"; one is for higher protein/lower carb.
  • Sorry, correction to above!
    I just checked the WW site. There are actually FOUR "PointsPies": balanced, higher carb, higher protein, and vegetarian. Despite the cutesy name, they're pretty helpful.
  • Bandit - I am currently doing SBD and WW at the same time. On Phase 1 I followed the menus in the SBD book and pointed out everything - I managed to stay within my point target and only use 1 or 2 flexpoints per day.

    SBD suggests using low fat yogurt and low fat cheeses. Also using Canadian bacon instead of regular. It took some work but I have managed to blend the two and it seems to be working for me - though combining programs may not be for everyone.

    Currently I have my meat and veggies but skip the rice/potatoes/pasta. I will make 2 different veggies instead or have a salad or soup for starters. When I do make the occasional rice or pasta dish I use brown rice or wholewheat pasta.

    WW ( in the new program) suggests using whole wheat and whole grain products instead of white flour. They offer lower carb but not no-carb, which I think is sensible since I don't want to eliminate and entire food group from my eating plan.
  • Thanks Mary & Mauve.

    A couple of weeks ago I read about the South Beach diet in a magazine & tried it last week, started on Mon & at my w/i was down 2.2#. I felt pretty good and this week have mostly stuck with it (had a few crunchy snacks a couple of nights). Have w/i again tonight so I will see how I did. I found it pretty easy to follow except breakfast was abit of a challenge. I eat at my desk at work & had some yogurt, celery, egg. I find eating meat at breakfast very strange. I think next week I will try adding some carbs for at least my breakfast & see how that works. But the diet overall is really good.

    Thanks again & bye for now.