Thanks, Dr. PJ.

That actually clarified something for me I hadn't been aware of. I am gonna ask my therapist if we can keep the lights/beeps on a little longer bc I feel almost like I dread having her turn them off, like I get into a groove and then am knocked out. Maybe that is a necessary part of it or maybe I could get deeper into it if it went longer. I'll have to ask her about it.
The reason I started EMDR was bc my husband, who I had been w since I was 19 (25 yrs ago!) fell in love w someone else and completely shocked me w it. I thought we were really happy and I was crazy about him and BAM it felt like I was blindsided. I spent the better part of four months miserable and in tears before I had two EMDR sessions over it (so far) and I am so amazed at how at peace I feel w the whole thing and that I am enjoying life and looking forward to my future again. My husband has mostly been sitting on the couch in tears lately but I just feel kinda done and excited about whatever is coming next. I dropped him off at the airport today and he's gonna be gone for a week and rather than missing him or looking forward to some sort of contact I was just relieved and free, got a bazillion things on my to do list done and had a really nice time w my kids. I was definitely progressing in talk therapy and on my own but I swear the EMDR made a night and day difference.
PatPat, The problem w being out of control is being out of control. What you say you do is not out of control, but in fact seems very controlled. You say you know the calorie counts before hand and then you stick to some set number and stop. I say bravo to that. That is what I'd like to do. I would not have felt the need to have any kind of therapy in relation to my eating if I could do that.
I am very impressed that you are so on top of things only 12 pounds into your journey, but I have to warn you that there have been times that I thought I had it all figured out, too, only to find later that it was more complicated. I have now been eating this way for just about three years and I am really not tempted to drop all I've learned about myself to start doing what works for you. I am two pounds below goal and even though I very much doubt that I have magically intuited some absolute answer to "how one should eat," I am going to stick w my woe.
LaurieDawn, I'm so happy it (or anything!) was helpful to you. I feel the same way about not knowing why or how. When I walk out of the office, I don't feel any different, but then thinking about the last two weeks since the husband-related EMDR, I am so grateful for the sharp turn I've taken.