I can really relate to what you are saying Glamourgirl. A lot. I have had the exact same pattern as you for so many years of my teenage and early twenties life. I did eventually overcome it for the most part but every time I gain weight due to a pregnancy it kicks in again when I actively try to lose weight. For example, I have been trying to eat "intuitively" for at least a year now and one of my biggest challenges has been that I wouldn't eat enough. I would take like 3 bites and be like oh yep Im satisfied!
hah. And then of course the later the day got I would be more and more hungry and finally just go crazy eating and feeding my starving body. Not usually junk but things like oatmeal and sandwiches.
It's been a long journey to get to where I am now and calorie counting actually helped me get over the restriction part as well. I started tracking how much I ate and realizing that if I had only had 400 calories all day I really did need some food. Then I got braver and started trying to eat more calories earlier in the day and I started to realize I didn't get that crazy hunger Im going to eat the house in the evening type thing. Ironically, counting calories got me in touch with my hunger and satisfaction points . But calorie counting isn't triggering for me. Now I finally have reached the point where I can eat until I am satisfied and its a lot more than I told myself was enough before, yet I feel good all day and don't go crazy at night eating anymore. And I am losing weight and have enough energy to start exercising now. So, I think your plan is a really good one. It sounds like you are doing great.