Here's my take:
Alli isn't a magic bullet. If you consume too much fat, you are likely to experience the oft mentioned unpleasant side effects. If you normally eat a low-fat diet, there's nothing for the drug to do. The drug does nothing about carb calories. Alli can interfere with the absorption of fat-soluble vitamins. And it's expensive. IMO, If you follow their diet guidelines, Alli really isn't doing all that much for you.
Let's do the math. The Alli web site recommends no more than 15 fat grams per meal. At 9 calories per fat gram, that's a maximum recommended 135 calories from fat. If Alli blocks 25% of fat calories as promised, then you are blocking a whopping 35 calories per meal, or 101 calories per day. Theoretically, then, Alli will help you lose one additional pound in 35 days (3500 calories). That's a pretty high cost per pound ratio if you ask me. I can more than pay for a gym membership with that and burn 100 calories in 15 minutes a day!!
Sure you could eat a pepperoni pizza and block 25% of mega fat grams, but you'd still be absorbing 75% of those mega fat grams and will likely lose the rest in a rather unpleasant manner.

I researched Alli, even tried it for a while. But it really didn't do anything for me that a balanced, calorie-controlled diet and exercise wasn't already doing.
