2frustrated - you look like a size 12, trust me!
I'm also 11st 12 (started off in July at almost 14 stone), and now I'm size 12 top half, 14 bottom half - sometimes even 12 depending on what it is. (Never jeans, though! Why does the size your measurements say you are never fit?!?)
And so the same weight as you... but I'm sure I don't look as slim as you!
Your post struck a chord with me as I'm wondering if I haven't got some serious body dysmorphia going on, now... I also still feel fat. My BMI will be *normal* at 11 stone 1 - so still best part of a stone to go. Yet I guess I look pretty average now - although the scales say I'm overweight, and I feel overweight....
Just curious... how tall are you? I'm five foot 6. Recently I've bought some new clothes and not tried them on first and got things too big for me - it's odd how you perceive yourself when you're used to being very overweight, then aren't anymore...
But I know exactly what you mean. Until the scales and BMI are *normal* I won't feel right - even though I'm already a 12. What's that about?
Phat x

but I think I'm getting used to my new body!