Hi minijaxgrl.
First, I would stay away from all the fake low carb stuff. IMO, they use all sorts of magic to claim their net carb totals...and to me, they're bogus. If you check the number of carbs and compare it to the net carbs...it seems impossible to magically turn the high number into the low number. Plus, they're not appropriate for induction...plus, they will kick-in all sorts of sugar and carb cravings. Oh...and plus, some of the ingredients in those bars...possibly glycerol or sugar alcohols...can give you stomach aches and the runs.
I'm rather militant about Atkins but that's because Atkins, for me, has been the difference between spending my life fat or spending it at a normal weight. And believe me, I've tried many of the other diets...it wasn't for lack of trying. I specifically remember, many years ago, doing calorie counting and being at work...and having my apple for snack...and 15 minutes later I was ravenous. And I remember going into almost a panic and thinking, "I can't do this".....and I'm not a person who gives up easily. If it works for me....I have tons of will-power. In fact, I haven't even needed will-power for Atkins...once the first 2-3 days was completed.
In fact...and I'm almost 58 years old here....it's now all about not only being a normal weight but also about eating "clean" for me (plus walking). And it's also about a plan I can stick with forever. For me, this is not a "diet" (which implies being able to go off it one day)....it's a "way of eating".....and for me, the benefits are so great, that it's totally worth it.
And the main benefits, IMO, in addition to the weight loss and being healthy and "clean"....is that 1) I'm never ravenously hungry, 2) the food totally satisfies me, 3) all my sugar cravings (including chocolate) are gone....and for ME, cravings always involved sugar and/or chocolate, so I can totally relate and 4) all bingeing behavior is a thing of the past and I can't even imagine bingeing like I used to do. In fact, there are sweets here (for my son) and they don't even faze me. I've had NO sugar since the beginning of last summer....and don't even miss it.
There are apparently some people who can do a modified Atkins and can lose weight....and there are those who do fantastic on a calorie-counting plan....and even those who do fantastic on a whole variety of eating plans on the forums here. But if being constantly hungry is the biggest threat to sticking to an eating plan, I think that Atkins should be considered.
deena