Idol Talk
 

We have so many fans here -- so I'll start this thread and we'll share.

So last night, of course my man Bo nailed it hard. ;) I think Travis will go, and most of us here agree. Probably it'll either be Constantine (a great personality but not the best voice) or Scott (a great voice but what a dork!) who will join him.

And for the girls ... that Janay has GOT to go! I wonder how she ever made it this far????

I'll be back with my favorite girl for tonight.

I voted for Jessica. I'm not sure who the other one is who'll go -- I guess we'll see tomorrow night!

Jim and I agree that Janay must go! We also don't like the 17 year old who reminds us of the Fran Drescher. Those are our predictions!

Okay..okay...don't know you guys but had to say that I think Janay needs to take a hike too. I don't really care for the "fran drescher" barbra streisand signing look alike either. The last gal (forgot her name) is good.
For the guys, I like Scott, but he is a definitely a dorker. Travis...he's got such a personality. Not the best voice but I love his smile. Constantine too. He is such a performer but the voice isn't that good. Love his hair and his smile. He has that little edgy thing going... :D My fav is my little blonde "nerd". ;) I think he has an awesome voice too. Bo has one too.
All and all, I'd have to say the guys sound alot better than the girls.

~chris

Hey, Chris. Do you mean Anthony Federov? I'm guessing that's who you mean because he does look a little dorky. I've been telling my friends here that he reminds me of Dennis DeYoung of Styx. Don't know how old you are so maybe you don't know Styx. I'd love to hear him sing Babe or some other Dennis DeYoung ballad.

Yep, I'm talking about Anthony. :D I remember Styx. I'm not overly old...I don't think (33 yrs old) but we listened to all that stuff in high school. I guess I could have described him as the "tracheotomy guy from the ukraine".... :lol: I know he looks nerdy but he has a great voice.

~chris

Well, my my my!!! It was surprising that Scott stayed instead of Nikko. As for the girls, I was indifferent to the three remaining. Mikalah won't last thru too much longer, I hope. She is so annoying.

Kathy, Jim and I agree with you completely. We were surprised at Scott staying (we thought people wouldn't vote for him because of his looks and "me" attitude from the beginning of the show). Mikalah is VERY annoying to me. She never sounds like she is on tune to me and I REALLY dislike her personality.

Okay I missed the results last night...So who is staying and who got the boot?

~chris

Steve Savold and Travis are out. Janay is also out but I can't remember the name of the other girl. I think the official website is IdolonFox.com. I'm sure it will be listed there just in case I messed it up!

Vickie, you're losing your mind! Scott Savol stayed -- Nikko Smith and Travis are out.

For the girls, the other one besides Janay was Amanda Avila.

Oh Yeah....you're RIGHT! I remember thinking he wouldn't make it and then he did. I do think he has a nice voice.

:lol: It's okay. We make certain allowances for you "retired folks"!!! :lol:

Brain cramp! Off to the treadmill. That should help. Haven't had breakfast yet. Maybe I can claim low insulinitis.

Mario just dropped out of American Idol. Cited personal reasons. Nikko is back, I think?

Lisa

Yeah, Lisa, I heard this too! Nikko is back for sure. I read it on the Idol official site. I don't think he should have been cut yet anyway. Wonder why Mario dropped out?

I wonder if they'll say anything about it tomorrow night? I heard "personal reasons" but that could mean a lot of things! I really like Nikko so I'm glad he's back.

Interesting twist of events. I'll be watching tomorrow and see what's going on with AI.

~chris

I heard another theory this morning -- that since he's getting close to the finals and could possibly win, he might have wanted to go with a different recording company for a better deal. From what they said, the AI contract is very strict and you are held to their rules; the ones who have not won have gotten better recording contracts than the actual winners, even though the winners get more publicity.

Who knows?????

What a disappointing night!

For me, it's either Constantine or Bo. I have to decide which very soon, because this year I am voting every week!

I was a bit disappointed in Anthony's song choice tonight but I didn't think he was as bad as Simon said. I still voted for him. Bo was incredible. I figured he didn't need my help. I just want Mikalah to be gone. She really irritates me.

Celena Rae lives here and was on my radio station this morning, giving her opinion of last night. She said that Lindsey would be going home tonight, which is exactly what happened. She's also really good friends with Nadia and it was very cute to hear her tell about Nadia calling her and doing some "girl talk".

Don't you all just wish the "nanny" would get the boot? She drives me nuts. Oh well...I'm rooting for Anthony (my little geek boy) and I'm a fan of Constantine and Bo. Hope I don't make any enemies by saying that.... :^:

Off to bed..

~chris

No enemies here!!! Bo is my man! And Constantine is a very, very close second! I still like Anthony a whole lot too, mostly for his look and his story.

As for girls, it scared me when Jessica got called over into the group of 3. She's my favorite because she seems so cute and sweet. In my gut though, I think Nadia will go the farthest of the girls. Some say (actually I think it was Celena who predicted it) it'll get down to Bo and Nadia and Bo will win.

And as for Scott -- I hate to say it but I like him more every week. I can see him going far and who on earth would have EVER predicted that???

No enemies here, either! I'm liking Anthony still but if he doesn't have some real great nights soon he may not make it to the last three or four.

Bo is doing great and I still like Constantine too but more for his charisma.

I thought Lindsey deserved to be in the bottom 3 for her last performance but I thought Mikalah should have gone, without a doubt.

Steve has a good voice but doesn't fit the stereotype at all. I hope he goes far. I'm enjoying this year alot.

Here's the scoop on what happened last night:

“American Idol” displayed incorrect phone numbers for three singers after Tuesday night's edition of the Fox show aired. At least one reality TV fan Web site, TVgasm.com, has announced that the network will air a new performance show Wednesday night (9 p.m. ET) and re-open the voting, with the results show moved to Thursday.

Screen captures of the episode show that incorrect phone numbers were listed for contestants Anwar Robinson, Mikalah Gordon, and Jessica Sierra. The phone numbers are always listed twice for each contestant, once as a number and once in a kind of shorthand, incorporating the letters on the phone that spell out IDOLS.

For Robinson, Gordon and Sierra, the numbers spelled out using letters were correct, but the complete phone numbers printed below those numbers were incorrect. Viewers who called the second numbers intending to vote for Robinson, Gordon or Sierra would be instead casting votes for contestants Anthony Fedorov, Carrie Underwood or Scott Savol.

The errors were not corrected before the show aired on the West Coast.

Aha! A rebroadcast of Tuesday night -- very smart!!

And still I think my gal Jessica Sierra totally nailed it.

In a tradition started here in Comiskey Park by my friend, Chicago White Sox Organist Nancy Faust, I'd like to bid a fond farwell to Mikhala!

Na Na Na Na, Na Na Na Na, Hey Hey Hey, Good Bye!

:lol: I was gone last night but raced right home to find out who got the boot! I was SOOOO glad it was her!

how come no mention of my girl vonzelle she was great on tuesday (well wednesday too) and yes mikala had to go...I wonder who is next, I'm attached to all of them. Especially nikko and jessica.

I thought Vonzell did better this week than any other performance so far! She is just the cutest thing too -- and I loved her little bio clip they did where it showed her in the mail truck singing.

I'm still keeping my fingers crossed for Bo and Jessica.

Nooooooooooo!!
 

Darn it! My girl Jessica got axed! :mad:

Sorry to butt in, but have been reading your posts. Vonzell is from my town and the whole city is Vonzell crazy! There are billboards and parties. We are all so proud of her. A teacher where I work knows her and says she is the sweetest and sincerest person she knows. One of the stores in our mall gave her 3 of the outfits that she has worn on the show. We are all so proud of her!!

My DD was pretty upset about Jessica leaving too, Kathy. I don't watch but generally listen in, while doing my computer stuff ... out of those bottom 3 (which, in my opinion, Nadia and Jessica did a much better job than several others who weren't in the bottom 3), Anwar should have been booted because he was, by far, so much worse than the girls were on Tuesday night. Oh well ... at least Anthony made it through, for Vickie's sake! And Bo will be a contender for you right up until the end! :)

Wow, Shelley!!! That's awesome! Celena Rae is from here and she's the biggest thing -- so I can just imagine how crazy it is there since Vonzell is still in! I thought Tuesday night she did that Whitney song better than Whitney! And it's nice to hear that she's a nice girl!

Anthony should be thanking his lucky stars and my dialing finger! I liked Jessica alot and I didn't think she should have been axed. I think Steve, Nikko, and Anthony should have been in the bottom three and Steve should have been axed.

Vonzell was amazing. I didn't think she had it in her, but I really enjoyed her performance on Tuesday. When she started singing on Tuesday, I looked at my husband and said "Oh, No a Whitney song, she's toast!" and then she was amazing. I, too, am glad to hear she's nice. Part of my problem with Steve is that horrible scowl and nasty loner persona he shows. I remember him from the beginning in the group project when he acted like he didn't want to play well with others!

I see this is an old thread, but I just had to post that I think Nikko got robbed tonight! I thought he was much better than Scott. Anyone else?

I don't care for Nikko much but I do agree that he was better than Scott.

I think the bottom third should have been still Steve and Nikko but also Anthony...Sorry if I offend anyone but he was terrible. I would like to see Bo and Nadia go to the final two.

Anthony is my favorite but he hasn't been picking good songs for the last two weeks.