Ooh, Kylie, you truly are a girl after my own heart!
I love the MAC eye products (their PowerPoint eye liners are fantastic - great texture and incredible colors) because they have a ton of pigment and are in very fashion-forward colors. I also like the Stila lip glosses, although they really do rip you off on the amount of product in the container (pet peeve, but the colors are so nice, and some of them taste HEAVENLY! I'm partial to Pomegranate...).
One small negative consequence from losing so much weight is that my face looks a little droopy and more wrinkly than it once did. I have taken to moisturizing like crazy. It's super pricey, but I *love* Kiehl's Cryste Marine face cream for the winter when my skin is dry. It gives my face a totally smoth texture in a way nothing else does. At this point, I just get samples everytime I go in, but I think they may be onto me... ha!
Also - something I'm trying during the winter months since I'm so freakin' pale is the Jergens Natural Glow moisturizer that's supposed to tint the skin gradually. I'm on only day three, so I can't really see it yet, but if it works I'll give an update.
It's funny - I'm such a tomboy in so many ways, but I do love my girlie amenities!