Quote:
Originally Posted by EagleRiverDee
I think with Dr. Oz, or any celebrity, you have to glean the good from the bad in what they say. I will still read the articles he's featured in but I'm going to use my own common sense.
I mostly agree, except that it seems to me, that as a physician (speaking as such, giving medical advice), Dr. Oz. should be held to a different standard than Paris Hilton.
But that's not how "edutainment" works, and I'm not sure that the average viewer realizes just how crazy some of his advice is, because he seems so caring, intelligent and sincere (he does have charisma).
And he also has an incredible talent at making nonsense sound reasonable, so it takes more than common sense to evaluate his advice. Much of what he says, you'd have to go to medical school to be able to evaluate.
In getting my BA and MA degrees in psychology, I had to take undergraduate and graduate coursework in bioology, chemistry, physiology, research methods, statistics and the psychology coursework also covered a good deal of human development, physiology (mostly brain physiology) and even nutrition.
Without that background, I'd have no way of "gleaning" the good from the bad. And even with it, I can easily get caught up in "hey that sounds perfectly reasonable," until I go looking for the science behind his recommendations (and again I need my science background to evaluate what I see online - because crackpot theories often have a lot of self-proclaimed experts "supporting" them. Recognizing fact from crackpot theory isn't easy without a strong science background, which most people do not have).