Great idea Skyra for starting this thread :-) I've also had my issues with pb and I literally thought I was the only who would love nothing better to do than sit there and eat it straight out of the jar :-p I've also experimented with different kinds. I definitely know that Jif and Skippy brands are automatic binge triggers because of the added sugar and just the smoothness/texture of it really grabs ahold of me. I recently bought a jar of Smuckers Natural Reduced Fat and it's been in my cabinet going on 2 weeks now. To be honest...seeing all the oil just sitting on top and having to stir the junk every single time I used it warded off binges for me. The oil kinda grossed me out lol But once I did get it all mixed and was able to put it on my sandwhich, it was still the same good ol pb taste. I guess it wasn't as accessable to me? I couldn't just take a spoon and dive right in the way i could with the Jif or Skippy brands. So even though I didn't binge on it I think I still managed to eat peanut butter and jelly practically almost every day lol So once I finish this jar I don't think I'll buy anymore for awhile but the next time I do I will def get this brand again. I felt pretty comfortable having it in the apartment. Good luck with everything Skyra....like you said, you shouldn't have to be dependent on anything, especially a type of food! :-)
~D~