I have been struggling for the right words to say. Probably tomorrow I will wake up and say... "WOW.... you handled that poorly" ... or "WOW .. you were totally off base". But it is not tomorrow... it is today... and this is how I feel today.
Tony... thank you so much for being honest with your answers. I was afraid that was why you were here.

I can only speak for myself.... but I do have a problem with being your
"extracurricular foray for a better understanding. "
That statement alone shows me that you really
don't understand .
But I... for one... come here to be with people who
DO.
That is why this 300+ thread was started. So we had a place to come .. to be with people who do understand. There are thousands of other weight loss groups in 3FC. All of them want or need to lose weight. But most of them can't understand either. Unless you have needed to lose OVER half your body weight... you cannot know what it is like.
I know you will say... that is why you want to come here... so you can know... but ...you can't. Just like I can't understand how anyone would beat or sexually abuse their kids... or sell their bodies for drugs. Unless you have been there... you can't.
You are not the first to come here to "study us". And I know you will not be the last.
This is an open forum ... no true privacy... just an illusion of privacy having our own little corner of the boards.
I do not think your "intent" was to pry... well.. maybe I do.

I think your heart is probably in the right place. BUT .... You are not here to share in our journey... you are here to "study our journey" ...
and I do have a problem with that.
If you want to do a study of obesity... then go to the main boards .. and start a thread entitled... " Would you let me learn from you"... or "Can I study your life to get a better understanding"... or any other HONEST title.
Be honest and UP FRONT ... and let those who want to be a case study
come to you and correspond with you. There are thousands of overweight women out there. There is probably even a few in this group here who would love to share their story and struggles.
Just don't join in on "any group" and use them without their full understanding and blessings.... for your "extracurricular foray".
Instead of making people like me have to leave their home group to NOT be your case study... START YOUR OWN GROUP. Just be honest with the participants.
You will get a much better insight from people who want to be studied than people like me who will just shut up and fade away.
This place is sacred to many morbidly obese. It is the only safe haven they have had in years. It is not that way for all.
I do not pretend to speak for everyone.
But I do know... I am not the only one who does NOT want to be ANYONES object of curiosity. This is NOT PERSONAL against you. Like I said... you are not the first to come here to study us. We did not want them to study us either.
I speak ONLY for myself. I am NOT a spokesperson for this group or any part of 3FC.
I am merely a FAT OLD LADY who comes here to be with people
who does understand.
I am sure I could learn a lot from you. Just as I could learn from doctors, ministers, nutritionists. They all have a place in helping overweight people.
BUT ... just as in Alcoholics Anyonymous... I am most helped by people who have been where I am .. or close to it.
Gee... I know I could/ should find better words to express myself. I am just so totally overwhelmed by the REALITY of my private little world , not being so private after all.
When I first came here to 3FC... I NEEDED the security of not being stared at... or judged.
I sort of feel it is my responsibily to provide that same safe haven for the next 300+ person hiding in their shell ... afraid of opening up in front of others.
Please please know... I am not mad at YOU. I am just feeling violated.
Sort of like just finding out that someone was watching me change clothes behind closed curtains.
I have always said .... "Feelings are not facts... they are just feelings" But this is how I feel. And although I hope you can understand.... I am also aware you probably can't.
I don't apologize for my feelings... but I do apologize for my hap-hazard way of trying to deal with these feelings inside of me. I wish I had the perfect words to express myself. tomorrow I will probably think of a dozen better ways to express myself.
okay... again... I am truly thankful for you keeping us informed on Andria.
but I Feel we are more of a curiosity to you ... I don't feel you truly belong in a 300+ thread.
Geeze... shut up 2cue.
