Thanks for responding girls!
FunSize - I have 1 Essie polish in Chubby Cheeks. I LOVE the color and my bottle has a nice consistency so perhaps yours is from a bad batch.
kisskiss - I admire the wide range of colors you wear. I'm a girly pink and purple and red kind of girl, but I'm going to start branch out soon.
JerseyGyrl - I googled Chicago Champagne Toast by OPI and that color is so pretty!