I enjoyed reading this:
http://www.amazon.com/Quest-Human-Be.../dp/0393040046
Shows how it is all totally in the eye of the beholder and "beautiful" can come in many ways.
I'm most attracted to natural beauty that is low key. I can appreciate a more high maintenance cultivated type as well like "Oh, that's striking" but I'm not attracted too it. It's too much work. A simple neat & clean will do and the easiest thing to put on is a smile.
Whatever else is bonus. To me it boils down to having confidence, feeling secure and comfortable in your own skin and being kind to others.
Clothes, make up, jewelry -- all nice accessories. But the main thing for me to find someone beautiful is how they are. I don't care how pretty they seem on the outsides with clothes and whatnot -- if they are ugly acting or mean... it just makes them ugly all the way through.
I know sometimes people have real health and body image issues to work through, and I certainly wish them well if they really are going to try to get better. But I just don't want to hang around it if they are not going to try to work on it.
It takes a real toll. My dad has bad self esteem and is very judgmental. It's leaked out all over the family for decades, colored his outlook, his world and while growing up, us too. It's very oppressive to be living under the "Can't do that! What will people think?" cloud. It also robs him (and others) of joys in life. He's never worked on his anger til late in life and even then only halfheartedly and now he's losing mental faculties. So imagine -- a whole life spent in the doldrums, being negative and ugly at people. It is sad.
Since I'm stuck with him, I have a very hard time being around other people who suffer from the same. They pick at themselves all the time, are pessimists, depressed, whatever. It's a lot of work to be their friend because they keep you at arms distance or they are super critical of you because they are critical of everyone and everything. The poor self esteem is what makes them not attractive to me, not their perceived body flaws.
So yeah... for me beauty carries most weight in the self esteem/self respect/kind to people bucket.
A.