Since y'all are in the biz, what would you advise?

I know PR and I know how to spin things, but this is tough--my old trainer wants all of us to write a testimonial, provide before and after pictures, etc. based on the recent Challenge. At first he sought feedback and I thought about offering constructive criticism, but then he hinted "be kind." Well, I'm not feeling so kind. The further I get away from it the more I realize, he screwed up with me.

Yes, he was great. FOr the 9 months I trained with him 6 months were good. Then things changed.

Guys, this Challenge was NOT a good experience for me (and had he done things differently, it could have been). In addition to the absolutely childish drama I had to deal with from him and two teammates, I had to create my own level of challenge (outside things), seek support elsewhere, and add to that gym management made the program lack communication and organization. Frankly, as a former teacher, I'd give it a C+ and that's being generous.

I figure I'll not think about it for a few days and not write it while I'm feeling any negativity, but frankly, the more I work with my new trainer, the more I get what I need (stuff my old trainer made me feel bad for wanting). I'm starting to realize it was him and not me, that that stuff I wanted was totally appropriate and necessary. Yes, I still got a workout, yes, I still lost weight and got fitter. I just know it could have been something more. I see how she really gets "customer service" part of the training relationship and that he didn't. (I'm loving working with her--I'm feeling challenged, connected, and protected.)

I'm struggling with this. I want to say, FU, not gonna write it, but if I don't, it just perpetuates the drama with him. You can ask how--well, when I see him now, he clearly holds something against me, whereas I have tried to put the past in the past and just move forward. I try to act with dignity and just be pleasant. If I can find something positive to say, it can feed at least some level with him so that things at least get more comfortable one day. And since I'm not leaving the gym, I will still see him. People Pleaser Me likes things to be cool with people--no drama....

If he wants testimonials and you feel you did not have a good challenge, I just wouldn't bother writing anything at all. It's voluntary - so don't feel obligated to do it.
He must not feel that bad about you if he asked you to do it.

I wouldn't do it. I could not, in good conscience, write something that I didn't believe. No matter what he thinks, you felt that you were treated very poorly and unprofessionally on a regular basis. How can you reward that behaviour with any sort of praise? I would never write something negative to try to cause trouble but I would also absolutely not write a recommendation or positive review or whatever you want to call it. JMI.

FYI, he asked all of us to per his VP. I wasn't singled out.

"How can you reward that behaviour with any sort of praise? " That's how I feel. But I can find the nuggets that were good and state them...I think. Then again, I spent 17 years in PR...so I'm used to trying to do this....

I would not write anything at all. If he asks you why not, tell him the truth, that you felt his level of service was below par, but that you didnt feel the need to write a negative review. You prefer to just let it go.

If he pushes you or gets nasty about it, write a full and honest review that gets submitted to his boss.

If you spin something positive that you dont believe, you are only hurting the clients he gets in the future on the basis of your testimonial.

Exactly what ennay said.

Me too

And me! You say you are a people pleaser, so try to think about it this way. You will be doing a disservice to his potential future clients if you recommend him when you don't think he did a good job. People are going to hire him based on your recommendation. You're probably going to see those people around the gym. They're probably going to recognize you, since he wants you to include pics with your testimonial. How are you going to feel when you see them?

I'm also a people pleaser and so non-confrontational I've decided I need to see a therapist about it. So, if I were in your shoes, I'd just ignore the request unless he asks about it again. This has the added advantage of not prolonging your contact with him; you can just ignore him when you see him in the gym. If he does ask about it, I might tell him what ennay said. But it's more likely that I'd just say I forgot about it and promise to do it soon. Then I'd just keep "forgetting" until he gives up, forgets about it, or goes to work for another gym. That way, you haven't actually turned him down, it's just that you are sooooo busy... Usually when people ask for something like this, they are asking a lot of people (which you know is the case here) and don't expect everyone to come through for them.

I agree 100% with barbara

I am also a people pleaser, and in this case I would just avoid the issue. Unless the guy asks you one-on-one, in person, just do not mention it.

maybe you can handle this easier if you turn it around and put the ball in his court: If he had treated you decently you would have done this with pleasure. Is there anything that he can do to make it up to you? Then next time, if he asks, says you will do it if he evens out the score first. let's be realisitic here, you paid for his services, and you were not satified, and he knows this.
If he was in your position, would you expect him to give you a good testimonial without some other effort on your side first ?

Rabbit