Hi, Turtles,
Judy, we won't yell at you. But I wonder about your choice of language. When you said that you want to "do well most of the time and 'binge' enough to stay at this weight", it made me wonder if the issue you're struggling with is feeling deprived, then overeating whatever you feel deprived of.
Perhaps you need to take a look at your journal and see if you tend to make food choices based on what you think will help you lose weight, rather than on what you want to eat. You can learn to stay OP and still eat the foods that you really like. It takes a little more effort than "doing the diet thing". But it's worth it because eating the foods you like (such as your mashed potatoes) can really help you to hang in there.
Also, be sure you're getting enough fat and points. Especially if you've started to exercise. Exercise often requires a change in our eating habits because our bodies fuel requirement changes.
I've noticed that I've been changing my ideas about what constitutes a meal, since I've started to do mini meals. I think part of tweaking WW so it works into our lifestyles is to rethink our preconceptions about food. A lot of traditional meal combinations are difficult to eat when I'm averaging 5-7 points per meal. So, I pick the item I really, really want and adjust the rest of the meal around it.
For example, if I were making the choices from your last night's meal and really wanted the comfort of mashed potatoes, I would have had the mashed potatoes with either a poached egg or mixed a point or two of grated cheese into the potato (Most restaurants will give you some cheese on the side if you ask for it.) If I wanted more bulk, I would have had a salad with lemon juice, salsa, or dressing on the side, depending on how many points I wanted to spend.
I won't choose egg white omelettes or dry toast for two reasons. One is that in my head, they're diet food. Those are on the list of foods I used to choose because I was on a diet, but I don't like either of those foods in that form. I only eat eggs if I have the points for the yolks, too. And I eat toast only if I can put something on it.
As for the toast in this meal, the only reason I can see that I might have ordered it is that it's traditional to have toast with eggs, so I'd order it out of habit. I'm learning not to do that anymore. I'm learning to make choices based on what I want, whether I have the points available, my nutritional needs, and not to eat refined carbs without protein. (The latter is a personal thing. I feel ill if I munch on a candy bar or something similar without eating some protein, too. So I usually eat them with a regular meal, rather than as a snack, as many people do.)
The other thing I noticed in your post is that you really worry about the scale numbers. But the scale is probably the worst indication of how much fat you've lost, especially if you've started exercising. So, I'd give it more time. And remember everyone has plateaus, no matter what they do.
Consider the possibility that you might need to take a break for a month or so to consider the program and how to best fit it into your life. Or to deal with some issues that have popped up. Or just to take a break. Sometimes after a break, our bodies will lose weight a little more steadily. I don't know why that happens, but I've experienced that in my life. I read an article once that recommended losing in increments. (Losing a certain amount of weight, then maintaining for a few months, then losing another set amount of weight.) Most people don't have the patience to do that, even if it might be healthier, as the article suggested
But, even if you decide to maintain your weight for a time, or forever, keep coming to the Turtle Club. We support you in whatever decision you make because it's your life and your journey. You have to do what's right for you. My experience was that continuing to come here is the main reason I didn't regain all of the wieght I lost prior to my decision to take a break and maintain my weight.
My day today is going pretty well. I'm going for a walk in a little while. My dh is picking up the rental car tonight for our trip to SF. I'm looking forward to it, except that the weatherman is predicting rain, just for the weekend. Then we go back to the dry, clear days we've had for the past two or three weeks. Frustrating! But it's going to be so wonderful to spend a day with my son. I hope we will learn that their financial aid package will allow him to go to art school. And I'm looking forward to seeing the art piece he's entering in the youth art show.
I'm OP. And feeling good about how that's going. I need to remember to take some water with me this weekend. Getting in the water is the hardest thing when I'm not at home. And I'll take my index card to keep track of what I eat when I'm not home so I can write it in my journal when I get back.
I'm not sure if I will be able to post this weekend. I'll try when I get back in the evenings. It will be such a busy weekend, since we're going to San Jose on Sunday, too. I'm really appreciating my dh being willing to do all that driving, with the extra trip to San Jose, so I can see my family for a little while.
Hope everyone has a great weekend!
Happy turtlin'!
Lin
272/233/225/135 or so