I've been thinking about this post, as evidenced by the fact that I keep poking my nose in.

I don't know why this post has so captivated me...maybe it's the word "panic". I know panic as it relates to weight and losing it and panic as it relates to social anxiety and believe me, it's all wrapped in there together.
I think there are two things at play in this thread:
1. Miriam, you want to lose the weight fast
2. You want to lose it without overhauling your lifestyles.
Which is more important to you? Neither of the above is wrong, in my opinion. But if your biggest desire is #1, to lose it fast, then I think Robin has it right. There is little room for error (or treats) in a plan for faster weight loss. Even then, I'm not sure there's a guarantee that it will come off faster, but there's a better chance if you follow her tried and true plan.
Robin's plan is too rigid for me. What I lack in the eating I make up for in exercise. I workout upwards of three hours a day right now because it's summer. I'm very rigid, just in a different way than Robin is. I like my chocolate too much.

But I've also reached a point where I can indulge without blowing my whole day and certainly without blowing the diet.
I think there's something to be said for absoluteness at the beginning of a new healthy lifestyle. Eventually the guard can come down a bit.