OK, time to get caught up on some personals!
Olehcat - Having done IF in the past and knowing that it worked for you, maybe it is worth another shot. You said that you would like to structure your meals to eat your biggest meal mid-day and a light meal in the evening but that you can't. What if you make your last meal your biggest? I know there are all sorts of different ways to IF, but I am basing my plan on the Leangains style. If you look at the website and take time to read through it there are some VERY interesing articles and studies regarding meal timing. One of them states that when having your largest and carb heaviest meal before you begin your fast again it actually has a positive correlation on your leptin levels and also helps you make it through your fasting period better. If you eat a small meal before fasting 14-16 hours it's not going to 'stick with you' as well.
I suggest that if you want to do IF again that you do a bit of research into it and WHY it can be effective for some people aside from just the idea of wanting to eat a larger meal. I don't want to sound like an ***, but it seems like you might be reaching a point of desperation and just want to find something that 'clicks' for you. I totally understand, believe me... but I fear that another 'failed' approach to managing your diet will only lead to more stress.
I also want to toss out there that whatever method you try, chances are it's not going to be EASY. You're going to have to make some effort somewhere; counting calories, watching carbs, doing IF, or some other such method. Rarely can people just eat willy nilly and not think about it and lose weight AFTER they have already been through phases of dieting. I don't feel like you can 'unlearn' what you know about calories and just be blissfully ignorant to them anymore.
Regarding how I feel (and thank you for asking); I've only been doing IF for a few days but physically I love it. My workouts have been great, I'm not hungry (at least not any more than previous mornings) and eating larger meals is super satisfying. I feel lighter during my workouts, more alert, and I know it's a placebo effect but I swear I feel the fat burning! LOL you'll have to read up more on Leangains about fasted state workouts and maintaining the fast AFTER the workouts, and it's effects on fat oxidation. (As a side note, I'm having coffee, BCAAs and L-Cartinine before my workouts to assist with that).
As far as how I feel my body LOOKs... meh. Its not like in a few days there would be any change, and I drank and ate too much with the hubby this weekend. Thursday wasn't bad, but then there was the unplanned outing on Friday that led to post binge-drinking pizza, chocolates and ice cream drunken munchies!
I don't think I'll see any results from this any time soon, as ultimately it's still calories in versus calories out. IF *SHOULD* help with adherence which is the most important aspect, but additional fat burning from fasting and fasted workouts would be lovely.
And yes... my hubby... he's a special breed.

I think you nailed it when you said that its about the build up and the subsequent let down. He pointed out that the winter weather has been a factor during the last few visits and I have to agree with him; when it's snowy and miserable out it's not as much fun -- no impromptu outings for hikes, drinks on the patio in the sun, BBQs with friends, and summer day trips.
Turbo - Welcome to the world of coffee fueled poops! LOL, a LOT of people say that their morning cup of joe is part of their routine and they can't do without it. Its the caffeine... gets your system moving!
Congrats on the fantastic run too! A personal best is always a huge boost to your self-esteem and just keeps you pushing through.
How do you feel about incorporating calorie counting again? I use MFP, but it's really only to see the breakdown of protein, fat and carbs. I am too lazy to add it all up myself.

I've always used a little notebook and I still do, but MFP is a nice 'sanity check'.
Jessica - I don't think that any perceived challenges would prevent me from getting a puppy at all!

I plan to crate train the little guy and honestly my hubby's house he's renting isn't exactly a dream abode anyway, so I'm not worried about him having accidents. LOL, I'll get him all trained up and good to go before we move into our NEW HOUSE!! HAHA
That is fantastic that not only are you 2nd in your competition (whoot whoot!) but that you feel great about yourself and a renewed sense of motivation. THAT is the most important thing, for sure.
Maddie - Could your TOM issues be stress related? I know that tends to throw things off for a lot of women.
Krampus - boo for the sudden and unexpected jump! Any progress with that coming down today?
Yes, I am LOVING the IF. I feel like this is just better for my body... my workouts are better and I don't feel as hungry. I know I'm preaching to the choir, but this is amazing and I'm actually angry I stopped all those years ago! Traveling yesterday was so much easier and inexpensive too, considering I only had to pack one snack and not run around trying to find something low calorie and healthy and EXPENSIVE to eat at the airport. Win!
I am recovered from my hangover, and as predicted, don't want to drink again for a while... haha. I got it out of my system!
I actually still eat 3-4 meals as opposed to the 2 that you do, but that's flexible. I'm sure I'll adjust things as I get used to the way of life, but so far it's fantastic.
Oh, spa day was fantastic! I love my friend who does my massages but going to a spa and NOT TALKING and just getting the treatment was amazing. I got a fantastic full body deep tissue massage and then we rolled right into a really nice facial. Perfect.

I'll have to make another appointment with her for my May visit to Colorado.
Alexis - Meeting my hubby's team was so much fun. I think he likes that I'm special ops as well and can relate to them in that way. I'm not a typical military spouse. One of the guys brought his wife out too, and she's super awesome. Her name is Kendra, and what I thought of when I met her was "she looks so much like
Krampus!" LOL, I hope to get to know her more, and to see all of them again in May before everyone takes off. I think a big family BBQ would be nice. Maybe I'll plan that...
I struggle to figure out what I 'should' be doing as well, and I think that's more normal than we would like to believe. What matters is that we keep trying, right? You did great getting your running done this past week and are being realistic about your goals for this week. Don't sell yourself short; most people don't do half as much or care nearly as much about what they eat! Baby steps, remember?
Pixelllate - I didn't know you did IF too! Nice!
LOL is it wrong that I would want to kick Suri and Katie? I don't feel like any kid should be that 'entitled' to stuff for no reason, but then again if I had that kind of money would I treat my kid any differently? I guess we'll see if she turns out to be a horrible person or not. :/
I'm feeling winter stir-craziness too, and I think it led to my boredom eating and drinking with my hubby this weekend (or made it worse anyway) so I feel you! Hopefully it will start clearing up and getting warmer soon!
** I know I missed a lot but I read it all, I swear! **