Hi lgordy~
I had some of the same problems. I did great on detox the first time. I lost 6 lbs. I ended up staying on detox for a few more weeks and lost 9 more lbs. I then progressed to phase 2 and proceeded to BLOW IT! I just couldn't keep myself from cheating here and there. Then, Thanksgiving came and I ended up with a 4 lb gain. UGH! I had no control anymore. My dh started FS with me in Sept. He has lost 47 lbs to date. He has had no problem at all. I have always had problems with portion size. I have a very healthy appetite.

I just don't know when to quit. So... to tell me that I can have as much as I want of veggies, fruit and beans is not a good thing. I went overboard. So.... I started counting my calories also. It has really helped me to see how many calories I am eating. I didn't just eat until I was satisfied. I ate until everything was gone. LOL! Leftovers just don't happen in my house.
Now I make sure that I am within my calorie range. I have lost 3.6 lbs this week. I plan out my meals a day ahead of time and print the menu out. Then, I just follow it the next day. When I get to the end of it... I am done for the day. I have done really good with it this week.
From looking at your detox menu... looks like you are getting all of your nutrients in. Are you getting enough calories?? I don't know the quantities of the foods you have listed. Maybe you could try to add another snack in after dinner.
What is your menu like for phase 2?
Are you still exercising? That is crucial. What about eating every 3 hours to keep your metabolism up? This keeps your body in fat burning mode.
Detox may not give you the results you want every time. Especially since you only have 26 more lbs to go until you reach your goal.
I think you should move on to phase 2 and count your calories every day. You may be binging because you are not eating enough. Also... I know that if I have "forbidden" foods in my house... I will more than likely eat them! So.. I don't buy things that I can't have. Simple as that.
You said that you do good if you have an outlined diet to follow... so do what I do. Make up your menus and follow them. I have to see exactly what I am supposed to eat for each meal. It takes some time to sit down and figure up what the calories are for everything, but it is so worth it. Then, I print it out and keep the menus for future meals. I have about 8 or so that I use over and over again.
Hope something I said helped.
I know I rambled on and on. SORRY!
Sherry
oh and drink plenty of water. Sometimes we mistake thirst for hunger.
Good luck!