I'm really glad you started this thread
I'm doing good with my weight loss.
I'm doing good - but by the skin of my teeth! - at not eating because of my mood but
I know that next on the list is to sort out my short and long term depression issues.
My only fear about any book is - how do we know it's telling us the truth? Or being helpful?
I read reviews for the 2 books you mention and they sound great - until someone else says they're a load of baloney. I know the baloney comments aren't necessarily true but that's my worry ~ how would I know? If I try a diet that makes me gain weight, I can stop and try something else. I'm too scared to try that with my mental health....