Canfield: Yes! that was crazy, and a miracle that the she delivered them safely!

I have made my decision.....
I choose #2. She is an adorable puppy, but not the "pick of the litter" When I described her as Spunky what I actually meant is that she always stands out because of her personality. She was the first one when only a few weeks old to feel comfortable being held, and always the first to run to me to be held. She also looks me right in the eye. She just melts my heart so I had to go with that above all. She is also the puppy that Bethany picked

So thanks everyone!! Your advice helped a lot

Looking straight in the eye, is actually dominance behavior, so be careful, it could mean she'll be a handful to train.