Hi Hannahboo.
I can only tell you what works for me......and of course, you are describing a situation at home, with your mom and her cooking/baking, that is not an issue I have to deal with....and that needs to be factored in also.
But....as for me, I have never been able to have success or to stick to a diet unless I am strictly low-carbing. It's like the difference between night and day for me.....carbs beget carbs. If I eat bad carbs...I am constantly hungry and constantly craving....yet I stop eating those carbs and suddenly doing this diet is a piece of cake (
) for me. I've not cheated even ONCE since I started quite a few months ago. AND, there are plenty of sweets here (for my dad and my son)....that don't even remotely tempt me.
I'm also on the same page as many of the posters here wrote in their replies.....that I MUST have rules. I do think that part of this is simply my OCD and also a bit of magical thinking.....a sort of "I'm safe as long as I NEVER cheat...ie: the diet gods will reward me.
I am quite comforted by the strict Atkin's rules and by having my Atkin's books here.
And lest anyone say this is a set-up for long-term failure....I did this back in the early 90's and kept the weight off for 10 years....until I was put on a medication that caused excessive weight gain....in 2005.
BUT...if you are anything like me (and I truly do think that I'm a classic carbohydrate addict)........low carbing may help you. It is SO much easier for me this way.....the constant hunger and the intense cravings are simply GONE. And I've not struggled one bit on this diet....as long as I stick to the carb restrictions.
Like I said, I have not cheated even ONCE......because really, nobody holds a gun to our heads and forces us to eat anything. It IS our choice whether to eat it or not. Sure, there are gonna be times when others encourage us or make us feel obligated to eat something off plan.....BUT, believe me, one CAN deal with these and not go off plan. We don't HAVE to eat anything we shouldn't. And for me, I NEVER make exceptions....because one would lead to two and two would lead to three......and *I* NEED strict rules. Not only that....but I also understand WHY these rules are working for me....which only reinforces why I need to strictly adhere to them and make NO exceptions.
So.....the bottom line here is that I can only tell you what is working for me. And if you are anything like me.....it might possibly work well for you. I know we are all different and what works for one person might not work for someone else.....but if what you're doing isn't working for you, IMO it's worth it to try something different.
deena