3 Fat Chicks on a Diet Weight Loss Community

3 Fat Chicks on a Diet Weight Loss Community (https://www.3fatchicks.com/forum/)
-   Weight Loss Support (https://www.3fatchicks.com/forum/weight-loss-support-13/)
-   -   how much is too much? (https://www.3fatchicks.com/forum/weight-loss-support/94608-how-much-too-much.html)

jcatron243 09-25-2006 01:16 PM

how much is too much?
 
This is yet another water question for everyone out there. There are so many good reasons to drink water, and plenty of it. Some people say half your body weight in oz, others say drink 64oz+8 oz for each 25 pounds over weight you are. Which seems to be close to the same number for my self so I try to drink 80-100 oz per day. Yesterday and the day before I found my self drinking 140 oz of water, that is over a gallon per day. I just don't want to cause an electrolyte imalance or something like that so how much is too much?

jillybean720 09-25-2006 01:28 PM

From my understanding, you really shouldn't worry about it. Unless you're chugging an entire gallon all at one time, you're likely fine (barring any kidney or other health problems).

I drink well over a gallon of water on most days (usually about 4 liters by 3pm), and I know some women on here drink over 2 gallons a day. I have yet to hear of it negatively affecting anyone (other than having to run to the bathroom more often ;) ). "Water intoxication" (I think that's what it's called) usually occurs in athletes who drink too much too quickly, not to people who drink their water throughout the day.

Heather 09-25-2006 03:52 PM

Then there are those of us who don't worry much about water at all! Don't get me wrong, I drink it and try to remain hydrated -- it is certainly important! It's just not something I focus on and I probably drink a lot less than many people here...

Kery 09-25-2006 04:05 PM

Depending on my activity, I average a good 4 liters of liquid per day, and I'm still alive. ;) Unless your doctor tells you otherwise (kidney problems, etc), you should be good with a gallon.

Now, be aware that after a while, if you get used to drinking a lot, it may cause you annoying side-effects if one day you don't drink as much. For instance, if at the end of the day, like 5-6 pm, I've drunk only 1 liter, I start to get headaches and feel cranky and tired. I've only observed this pattern on days when I can't drink enough due to circumstances I have no control over, so it's likely related. But effects may vary from person to person, too.

jcatron243 09-25-2006 06:57 PM

Thanks for the input. I love drinking water, and I always have. I need to get in at least 60 oz before 5pm or I do get a headache, then I drink my remaining 60 oz between 5-10 whilst at work. Suprising enough I don't pee all night, but I also walk at 10pm for 45 minutes after work with a group of co-workers (well most nights).

BlueToBlue 09-25-2006 08:55 PM

Wow! You all are very impressive water drinkers. Most days, it's about all I can do to drink 20 oz of water. I'm just not that thirsty.

- Barbara

midwife 09-25-2006 09:04 PM

I get headaches if I am dehydrated too.

I drink different amounts depending on how dehydrated I am or how much I have exercised. I drink until my pee is very very pale. Then I am hydrated. Dark pee makes me nuts...TMI I am sure, but it makes me nuts when my patients' pee is dark too.

callystia 09-25-2006 09:09 PM

Midwife, I agree completely. If my pee isn't pale I HAVE to go guzzle a great big glass of water. :lol:

ZedAus 09-26-2006 08:28 AM

I'm not sure how you all do it. I have trouble even getting in the two litres that 'they' say you should have. I truly have to force it down, as I rarely feel like drinking. Even when I don't drink much I am going to the bathroom constantly, averaging 3 or 4 visits per night as well. I was told that once you drank more, your body would adjust and you wouldn't need to go to the bathroom as often. Well, recently I tried upping my intake LOTS and after 8 weeks, I didn't see a change in the bathroom visits, so I'm not sure how long it is supposed to take to adjust.

In the summer I drink a little more, but certainly still not as much as I should. I DO eat a LOT of fruit and vegetables, so I am wondering whether I get enough fluid from them. I mean a L-O-T of fruit and vegetables.

Zelma

Heather 09-26-2006 08:45 AM

Zelma -- One of the reasons I worry about water less is because I know that there is a lot in the food we eat (esp fruit and veg, soups, etc). Also, it seems that the idea that we need "8 8 oz glasses of water/day" is a difficult one to trace the origin of and may be one of those "urban legends." See:

http://www.snopes.com/medical/myths/8glasses.asp

Some have tried to trace the original statement, and the doctor who may have made it spoke of liquids more generally and said that coffee etc could count toward hydration. In other words, yes, we need hydration, but that can come in many forms.

Please don't think I'm being anti-water. I'm not. It's VERY important to stay hydrated!

I think for a lot of people, water helps keep them full, provides a goal, etc. It's hard to overdo it, and does have tons of benefits! So why not drink if you're so inclined?

But if you don't want to focus on it, and are keeping hydrated, I think that's fine too.

Misti in Seattle 09-26-2006 09:01 AM

I also drink huge amounts of water. I have always drank a lot because I like water... but now I intentionally guzzle it by the liter. LOL I too go drink more if my pee is not pale enough. :) I can tell a big difference when I don't drink as much. Actually I start my day with fresh lemon juice in 32 oz of warm water.

Regardless of whether or not it is "urban legend" as to how much it helps I can definitely say I FEEL a lot better when I drink it AND I don't get nearly as hungry. So in this case (and since I know it is nothing harmful for me) even if it is "all in my head" I don't care, as long as it works! :lol:

OneKim 09-26-2006 09:58 AM

I don't focus on water either. I drink it through an 8 hr shift at work, mainly because it's cheaper, and because 'some' of the supervisors are enforcing the 'water only up front' rule. Usually around 20-40 oz in a night...other than that, I have to MAKE myself drink it at home.

It's good for you...but I have heard of it washing out electrolytes and blah blah blah. How authentic THAT is....NO idea! My mom drinks water only and she's not washed out anything...lol.

Yeah, the pee thing...I can tell by my urine how well I've been drinking. Alot of sodas make my urine very dark....

Kim

Heather 09-26-2006 09:35 PM

Quote:

Regardless of whether or not it is "urban legend" as to how much it helps I can definitely say I FEEL a lot better when I drink it AND I don't get nearly as hungry. So in this case (and since I know it is nothing harmful for me) even if it is "all in my head" I don't care, as long as it works!
Misti -- You nailed it. I think if water works for you, do it! I just think that sometimes there are people here who think they HAVE to drink it or that they're a failure at this if they don't, and I want to let them know that may not be the case!

LLV 09-26-2006 11:39 PM

I drink water when I'm thirsty, lol.

Seriously, I don't 'force' myself to drink more water than I want. I love my ice water and always have a glass of it hanging around somewhere. In fact it's the first thing I do when I get up in the morning after brushing my teeth and washing my face and all that fun stuff - I go get a big glass of ice water and I fill it all day long. Usually I just sip at it. I keep it handy for when I'm wanting a drink of it. But I don't force myself to drink more than I feel like having. Some days I have quite a bit, other days I don't drink much at all.

Kery 09-27-2006 12:30 AM

I don't know if this water thing is a urban legend, or if it's based off serious facts. I remember having read once (can't remember where, though) something along the lines of "Americans nowadays often think they're hungry, when in fact it's thirst, and since they can't tell it from hunger, they eat when they should drink instead". I'm sure it's worth for people from other countries as well, of course, it just must've been written by a person in the US, is all. ;) But maybe it could explain that bit of encouraging people to drink this-and-that quantity per day.

Me, I've always been a big drinker, so I know this is not "my" excuse. :lol:

jillybean720 09-27-2006 05:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LLV (Post 1419353)
Seriously, I don't 'force' myself to drink more water than I want.

I don't force the water, either. However, I've read (and recently confirmed this in a quiz about water in the 300+ section!) that the average body loses up to 10 glasses of water a day just through things like urination sweating, etc. Since there's no way for me to measure the amount of maoisture I get from my foods, I figure the least I can do for my body is replenish what it loses naturally :^:

Of course, I go above and beyond with 4 liters a day, but I don't always do it intentionally (I do focus on it more if I know I've been taking in a LOT of sodium lately). I just keep a 1-liter bottle on my desk at work and 1 in the fridge, so I keep switching them out throughout the day and sip constantly while I'm working. I never chug a bunch just to get in a certain amount or anything like that
:dizzy:

LLV 09-27-2006 08:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jillybean720 (Post 1419470)

Of course, I go above and beyond with 4 liters a day, but I don't always do it intentionally (I do focus on it more if I know I've been taking in a LOT of sodium lately).
:dizzy:

Yep, me too. I definitely drink lots more water if I know I've taken in a lot of sodium.

I rarely ever feel TRULY thirsty, so I'm probably getting the water I need. I'm in the bathroom quite a bit as well. So what I'm taking in simply because I WANT to take it in is most likely enough. I can always tell when I haven't had enough water on a particular day because I get that uncomfortable feeling in my feet, which means I'm retaining water. I also get charlie horses in my calves and cramps in my toes. That happens rarely these days. It used to happen a LOT. Before I started my weight loss journey. Because I know for a fact that I wasn't getting enough water then. I was walking the earth every day dehydrated and didn't even know it. In fact I was dehydrated so bad once, they stuck me in the hospital for 4 hours hooked up to an IV to replenish my fluids.

JayEll 09-27-2006 09:06 AM

If you ever have a kidney stone, you will become a water drinker! :stress: Some people have more of a tendency to form these than others, but not drinking enough water is part of it. I almost never feel thirsty, much to my detriment. I have to track my water intake. I try to drink 8 oz. every hour during the day--that means I usually get my 8-10 glasses in. If I'm exercising I drink more.

My kidney dr. says water means water--not fruit, not juice, not soda, not coffee or tea. Water.

Jay

Tisha___ 09-27-2006 09:46 AM

If I don't drink water, I end up drinking Diet Coke, so this past week and a half (since I started my journey) I've cut down to 2 Diet Cokes per day and the rest is bottled water. Even if it's out of the tap, I put it in a bottle, just because I'm curious how much I drink...not because I'm making myself drink a certain amount.

So, each bottle is 16oz. I drink one with breakfast, one after lunch, one with my afternoon snack, one with dinner, one before bed. That adds up faster than you realize. I've been drinking at least that much every day so far, and most days it ends up being closert to 100oz.

Going from having water maybe once a week (no, seriously.) to having that much every day, has really helped me a lot. I feel better. I'm not as tired. It helps me with cravings. It's been great. :)


jillybean720 09-27-2006 10:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tisha___ (Post 1419662)
Going from having water maybe once a week (no, seriously.) to having that much every day, has really helped me a lot. I feel better. I'm not as tired. It helps me with cravings. It's been great. :)

Same here--I used to literally almost NEVER drink water. Growing up, I drank lots of juice, soda, and milk, but would never drink water. Never. Now I drink water more than anything with maybe 1 can of diet soda a day and the occasional glass of skim milk (maybe 2 a week).


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 03:57 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.