Quote:
Originally Posted by tinneranne2
It is really insulting to me that she apparently thinks we are the same size. Ya know, except for her way smaller butt.
I think it's really crazy and horrible that size is seen as so horrible that it's ok and even flattering if someone smaller than us thinking they are our size or bigger, but it's not ok if someone larger than us thinks they're the same size or smaller.
There was a makeover show on not long ago that would make the featured women estimate their body size by putting themselves in a line-up of smaller and larger women, and almost universally the featured women estimated wrong in the fatter direction. I began to wonder whether the women did it on purpose out of fear of the stigma of picking "too small."
There was also a research study that found that of average weight women, the women with the best self esteems were the most accurate in the estimation of their body size and shape - whereas of plus-sized women the women with the best self esteems consistently underestimated their body size. One of the theories put forth by the researchers was that "fat" was so stigmatized that the best coping strategy fat women had, was perhaps denial.
When I was working, I was once complaining about finding nice, affordable business clothes "when you're fat." And my coworker blurted out, "you're not fat," and I burst out laughing - hysterically (on what planet is nearly 400 lbs, not fat). She snapped angrily, "you know what I mean!"
And I did, sadly. Fat is such a horrible and evil concept in our culture, that an intelligent, friendly, funny woman like me couldn't possibly be fat, so I had to be something else (and my favorite punchline to this story is that I'll slap anyone who says it's "fluffy").
I don't like euphemisms for fat, but I do accept most of them our of social courtesy (except for fluffy - I am not a sheep).
What I do hate is the untrue assumptions about fat and fat people, and the huge social taboo against underestimating my own size in comparison to others - and even the expectation that I must pretend that I'm larger than I am - and the expectation that others must pretend I'm smaller than I am.
Ideally I wish there weren't so much emotional baggage and social pressure against the social sin of making a mistake in underestimating one's own size or overestimating someone else's.
I know it's a social taboo that many people accept wholeheartedly, but things would be so much easier if we didn't have to be afraid of comparing ourselves to others, and possibly even being "wrong" without the risk offending others.
But that's the reason that giving clothing is so taboo - because the risk and consequences of being wrong are so great. If we overestimate the person's size or underestimate our own, it's a social crime of the century, and if we actually use words that reference size, it's essentially unforgiveable.
Heck, most of what we discuss on this site would be unacceptable in the real world.