3 Fat Chicks on a Diet Weight Loss Community

3 Fat Chicks on a Diet Weight Loss Community (https://www.3fatchicks.com/forum/)
-   Weight Loss Support (https://www.3fatchicks.com/forum/weight-loss-support-13/)
-   -   Any problem with tea??? (https://www.3fatchicks.com/forum/weight-loss-support/189947-any-problem-tea.html)

kellost 01-06-2010 01:09 PM

Any problem with tea???
 
Hey guys....looking for a little advice on tea. I've posted here before that I've had a lot of trouble curbing my snacking in the late afternoons/evenings. So something I've been doing is drinking hot tea with Truvia or Splenda to prevent myself from eating too much at those times. I'm drinking decaffenated herbal fruit teas (like Raspberry tea, Peach tea, etc), so it's not affecting sleeping or anything. I've been having several cups of tea between the hours of 4:00 and 8:00 pm. It is helping a lot!

Can you guys think of any reason this would be bad for me? As far as I can tell, it's 0 calories and 0 fat. The only thing I could think of is that tea can yellow your teeth, but I'm trying to brush really well afterwards.

Thanks everyone!!!

Amba Dawn 01-06-2010 01:16 PM

I don't think there's anything wrong with it! I'm actually doing the same thing to break my coffee addiction. Until now I used to drink several cups of coffee in the morning (usually 4-5, sometimes more). Not only is it a lot of caffeine, I can't drink black coffee...so I use fat free creamer...which isn't too bad on calories (and no fat), but it has quite a bit of carbs. So I'm drinking green tea in the mornings...it has a little caffeine, but not nearly as much as coffee. And I drink Raspberry herbal tea at night to get through my late-night food cravings. So far so good! :)

BarbPA 01-06-2010 07:02 PM

I don't see any problem with it. I drink a cup or two of hot tea in the morning, have an iced tea with lunch and then maybe herbal teas in the evening. I sweeten them with Splenda. I also drink lots of water.
:D

WaterRat 01-06-2010 07:39 PM

I often drink an herbal tea in the late afternoon/evening, usually with no sweetner. I also sometimes drink black tea with about 1-2 tsp of skim milk. I don't see any problem though personally I avoid artificial sweetners.

Palestrina 01-07-2010 08:44 AM

It's good you're trying to replace a bad habit, but I would personally not want to replace it with artificial sweeteners. Studies show that people who consume altered foods (for example sweeteners, low fat or no-fat labeled foods, etc) actually gain weight over time.

Some teas can be good for you. Look into drinnking green teas which provide lots of antioxidants. I've replaced coffee with lemongrass green decaff tea.

stargzr 01-07-2010 10:02 AM

YUM! I love hot tea! The only thing that I haven't seen posted yet, is that tea isn't water... In that, it's not hydrating you to drink it. So, just as long as you keep your water intake for the day fairly high, I don't see a problem with it. :)

eroica27 01-07-2010 10:44 AM

i like rishi's roobios teas and mint teas as well. those i buy loose and because of their natural flavors don't go well wih add-ons, i don't have to add extras to them

Botzz 01-07-2010 10:56 AM

I drink a gallon of green tea per day and have lost more than 200 pounds doing so :) I say drink as much as you want to, in fact it helps and I have experimented with it and lose more when I drink green tea vs just straight H2O. The caffeine in green tea is very minimal and a whole gallon has about the same as 1 cup of coffee but it is spread throughout a day instead of all at once like in a cup of coffee so there is no effect from it in my opinion. I have been at this for just over 2 years now and cannot notice any yellowing of my teeth from it either :)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wannabeskinny (Post 3080278)
It's good you're trying to replace a bad habit, but I would personally not want to replace it with artificial sweeteners. Studies show that people who consume altered foods (for example sweeteners, low fat or no-fat labeled foods, etc) actually gain weight over time. .

I have used splenda for more than a year and a half in my green tea and am steadily dropping weight *shrug* more than 200 pounds total so far.

As Ever
Me

paris81 01-07-2010 11:25 AM

I've heard that tea is really good. If you do decide to go with green tea, there are lots of benefits from that, but be sure to get the decaf kind (unless it doesn't affect you late in the day). I wonder though if the decaf kind has the same benefits, I have not idea. But in general, there's nothing wrong with tea.

JulieJ08 01-07-2010 11:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by stargzr (Post 3080412)
YUM! I love hot tea! The only thing that I haven't seen posted yet, is that tea isn't water... In that, it's not hydrating you to drink it.

I beg to differ! :)

Botzz 01-07-2010 11:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JulieJ08 (Post 3080617)
I beg to differ! :)


I second that!

luvchuchu 01-07-2010 12:17 PM

What about Acai Berry Tea and Blueberry Tea? I bought some of this at the store the other day and have yet to try them.

westernsoutherngirl 01-07-2010 12:33 PM

There are two teas I can drink without adding sweetner which i am trying to avoid but i will use truvia in a pinch - Celestial Seasonings "Candy Cane Lane" or "Gingerbread" sometimes you can only find them at the holidays so I try to stock up. Both are decaf green tea or at least you can get them that way!

Altari 01-07-2010 01:00 PM

Problems with tea? O yeah. I spend waayyy too much money on loose leaf tea every month. That's a big problem. :)

rachinma 01-07-2010 01:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by stargzr (Post 3080412)
YUM! I love hot tea! The only thing that I haven't seen posted yet, is that tea isn't water... In that, it's not hydrating you to drink it. So, just as long as you keep your water intake for the day fairly high, I don't see a problem with it. :)

Yes it is. If it's decaffeinated, it provides the same hydration benefits, assuming you are not steeping herbs designed to dehydrate.


To the OP: I drink a lot of hot water with lemon.

Palestrina 01-07-2010 03:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Botzz (Post 3080528)
...I have used splenda for more than a year and a half in my green tea and am steadily dropping weight *shrug* more than 200 pounds total so far.

As Ever
Me

I was addicted to chemical sweeteners for over a decade. The hardest thing I ever had to do was to give up equal and diet sodas. I consider it a big accomplishment for me so please don't knock it. One day you may realize what those chemicals do to your body and try to quit and I wish you the best of luck when that happens.

losinflab 01-07-2010 04:04 PM

I love tea & drink a lot of it,but don't use any artifical sweetners because of migranes.Bigelows Constant Comment is a fav.Green tea...to me...has no flavor, so I use one green tea bag & one of CC together.I count tea as part of my water.....works for me.

Thighs Be Gone 01-07-2010 04:08 PM

I drink coffee...love it..it really helps me...Truvia has MSG in it so don't be alarmed if the scale slows--MSG really makes me puffy. It is just fluid retention though. Good for you to figure out that tough time--I have a bad problem during that same exact time frame!

Thighs Be Gone 01-07-2010 04:09 PM

Wannabe,

I think you are SPOT ON with the sweetner comment. I am still addicted to the sweetners despite my efforts to get off them. There is definitely much more to health than a number on a scale.

Botzz 01-07-2010 04:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wannabeskinny (Post 3080278)
Studies show that people who consume altered foods (for example sweeteners, low fat or no-fat labeled foods, etc) actually gain weight over time.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Botzz (Post 3080528)
I have used splenda for more than a year and a half in my green tea and am steadily dropping weight *shrug* more than 200 pounds total so far.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wannabeskinny (Post 3081213)
I was addicted to chemical sweeteners for over a decade. The hardest thing I ever had to do was to give up equal and diet sodas. I consider it a big accomplishment for me so please don't knock it. One day you may realize what those chemicals do to your body and try to quit and I wish you the best of luck when that happens.

Nobody is "knocking" anything and not to hijack a thread, but I applaud you for beating an addiction, most cases of people being fat (I am not going to sugar coat it we're fat ;)) deal on some level with addiction so anyone that has dropped a significant amount of weight deals with an addiction on a daily basis, what that has to do with your reply to what I posted I can't figure out as my reply was directly related to your comment. Also any study that shows that, in my opinion is most likely bias opinions from someone that has something to gain by the results because if I can drop more than 200 pounds and use a "sweetener" on a daily basis while doing so sort of shoots all kinds of holes in those studies.

and as far as "when that happens" goes, I am not worried about that ;) what I WAS worried about was dieing young and above 500 pounds, which I have remedied by eating healthy and moving more over the last 2 years.

sorry for the slight hijack, I just felt the need to respond ;) :carrot:

As Ever
Me

Thighs Be Gone 01-07-2010 07:07 PM

Bottz--I agree.

My adoptive mom is morbidly obese--probably super category. When I was helping her (and she was receptive) I felt the same as you. ONE BATTLE AT A TIME! I was more worried about her dying (and am still worried) from obesity than risk factors that may or may not be associated with sweetners.

For myself I was just ready for the weight to GO! I have tried other sweetners, more natural things, whatever but seem to gravitate to Splenda every time. I really hope to conquer it at some point.

beaka 01-07-2010 07:20 PM

Can anyone tell me if chai is considered a herbal tea? I really like it, and I've been drinking a lot lately with light vanilla soymilk.

JulieJ08 01-07-2010 10:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by beaka (Post 3081603)
Can anyone tell me if chai is considered a herbal tea? I really like it, and I've been drinking a lot lately with light vanilla soymilk.

It depends. Chai actually just means tea, although it's commonly used to mean spiced tea. Normally, that would mean real tea (black tea). However, there are companies that put out herbal "teas" flavored with the spices of "chai." So you have to look at the ingredients.

LovebirdsFlying 01-07-2010 10:59 PM

My favorites are lemon, chamomile, and peppermint.

Martina 01-07-2010 11:19 PM

herbal teas are good for you, especially green and white teas.

I've drank Sweet Tea all my life (for those that don't know, thats regular black tea with sugar in it) and am trying to curb that habit by drinking herbal tea with honey in it to sweeten it.

JulieJ08 01-07-2010 11:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Martina (Post 3082129)
herbal teas are good for you, especially green and white teas.

Just wanted to make sure every knows green and white teas are not herbal teas. They are true teas, and are not caffeine-free.

Sskar 01-08-2010 02:35 AM

I too have been using an evening hot-tea "ritual" to substitute for evening snacks, especially since one of my new eating behaviors is to NOT eat after 7 pm. I bought some new mugs, great tasting green and white teas to add to my collection of herbal teas, and a Capresso Water Kettle for a rapid boiling. (Works great for my morning French press coffee too.)

I don't use sweeteners because I find they stimulate my "sweet receptors" - although there isn't any evidence to show that is true in general. Also, just like ex-smokers start discovering how good food tastes once they quit cigarettes, eliminating sweetening anything has let me experience the delightful taste of food as nature intended.

fatmad 01-08-2010 07:05 AM

more on tea
 
My turn to chime in: I agree that in general a hot tea beverage is a great thing to avoid snacking. I personally had to cut back on tea drinking, because I usually snacked with it, having cookies with my afternoon tea.
Both black and green teas have antioxidants so have benefits. SInce cutting back caffeine I can only have decaf in the afternoons, and not even that in the evening.
Herbal teas (I prefer the term tisane, to differentiate) only have caffeine if its added or the herbs have it, but beware, lots of specialty teas like "blackberry" etc may be black tea with flavouring, and have lots of caffeine so read labels carefully.
I also wonder if some of the fruit teas (especially herbals) are really calorie free? Are they getting flavour from dried fruit in the mix? If so, they could be natural sugars coming out and affecting you. Not sure on this.
I don't think, unless you drink a ton of black teas you will yellow your teeth tho, I have no major problem and have been drinking several cups of black tea a day since age 10.
hmm
maybe we should organize a virtual tea party!
no cream cakes please tho:D

Altari 01-08-2010 10:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by beaka (Post 3081603)
Can anyone tell me if chai is considered a herbal tea? I really like it, and I've been drinking a lot lately with light vanilla soymilk.

What you would typically consider a "chai" is *technically* a tea, as it's made with herbs/spices and not beans. The additions of [soy]milk and sugar negate most of the benefits of drinking tea, though. :(

As someone else pointed out, "chai," itself, just means "tea" in most Indian languages. "Masala chai" is the beverage we consider "chai," although it's significantly different from real masala chai. We ordered some at an Indian restaurant, and it was simply a mix of (from what I could taste) cardamom, cinnamon and, I think, masala spices. No sugar, milk or anything else.

Altari 01-08-2010 10:43 AM

((Sorry to chime in so much. Tea is field of personal expertise. If you could only see my kitchen...))

Quote:

Originally Posted by fatmad (Post 3082446)
Both black and green teas have antioxidants so have benefits. SInce cutting back caffeine I can only have decaf in the afternoons, and not even that in the evening.

Try getting some good loose leaf tea instead of decaf teas. If you like green, start with a variety called "Dragon Pearl" (sometimes called "pearled" or "balled" jasmine). It's got an oddly sweet taste. And, even though it's naturally caffeinated, you can brew the leaves four to six times. Most of the caffeine comes out in the first brewing.

Quote:

I also wonder if some of the fruit teas (especially herbals) are really calorie free? Are they getting flavour from dried fruit in the mix? If so, they could be natural sugars coming out and affecting you. Not sure on this.
Most fruit teas don't have fruit pieces in them. Blood Orange Black teas, for example, have blood orange peel, not orange pieces. Most lemon teas have lemon grass, lemon balm or lemon peel. Good blackberry/raspberry teas will use the leaves.

I've seen a few teas (usually of unfortunately low quality) that have dried fruit pieces, but those have so many "extras" ("natural flavors" and other unnamed ingredients) that they've stopped being tea and become more of a dried, uncarbonated soda. My daughter just bought a bag of "strawberry" tea, which comes with leaves presoaked in strawberry juice then redried. ><


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 08:40 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.