Sexiest Man Alive Game #2

You're on Page 1 of 7
Go to
  • Ok, we're going to try this again, but we'll do it with our OWN choices, not People Magazine's!

    The rules:

    First we'll take nominations. Post one name, and wait until someone else has posted before you post another (in other words, don't go twice in a row). Copy and paste the list in the previous post and add your candidate at the bottom.

    When we've received enough names (how many should we go to -- 25 or so? Feel free to suggest a number), we'll start eliminating each other's choices. Don't get mad at each other, though -- taste in such things is wholly subjective! Remember, we're not removing anyone until we get a full list of 25 (or a different number if you guys suggest otherwise -- I'm open to whatever).

    I'll post the first nomination:

    Johnny Depp
  • I'm sticking with Hugh Laurie
  • Johnny Depp
    Hugh Laurie
    Robert Knepper
  • 1. Johnny Depp
    2. Hugh Laurie
    3. Jonathan Rhys Meyers
  • 1. Johnny Depp
    2. Hugh Laurie
    3. Jonathan Rhys Meyers
    4. Shemar Moore
  • 1. Johnny Depp
    2. Hugh Laurie
    3. Robert Knepper (this one was skipped)
    4. Jonathan Rhys Meyers
    5. Shemar Moore
    6. Denzel Washington
  • 1. Johnny Depp
    2. Hugh Laurie
    3. Robert Knepper
    4. Jonathan Rhys Meyers
    5. Shemar Moore
    6. Denzel Washington
    7. T.I.
  • 1. Johnny Depp
    2. Hugh Laurie
    3. Robert Knepper
    4. Jonathan Rhys Meyers
    5. Shemar Moore
    6. Denzel Washington
    7. T.I.
    8. Robert Pattinson
  • OK....so it IS true...women have stopped thinking I was "sexy"....all because of Angie I'll bet...she owns me...

    women stopped checking me out years ago....I KNEW she put a hex on them...I knew it....just couldn't prove it! Now I know....

    but how in the heck did she know to hex them "years" before we met?

    Go figure.....
  • 1. Johnny Depp
    2. Hugh Laurie
    3. Robert Knepper
    4. Jonathan Rhys Meyers
    5. Shemar Moore
    6. Denzel Washington
    7. T.I.
    8. Robert Pattinson
    9. Wentworth Miller





    I say we do 50!
  • 1. Johnny Depp
    2. Hugh Laurie
    3. Robert Knepper
    4. Jonathan Rhys Meyers
    5. Shemar Moore
    6. Denzel Washington
    7. T.I.
    8. Robert Pattinson
    9. Wentworth Miller
    10. Simon Baker

    50 sounds good, Pear!
  • 1. Johnny Depp
    2. Hugh Laurie
    3. Robert Knepper
    4. Jonathan Rhys Meyers
    5. Shemar Moore
    6. Denzel Washington
    7. T.I.
    8. Robert Pattinson
    9. Wentworth Miller
    10. Simon Baker
    11. Jeffrey Donovan (Michael Weston on Burn Notice....sigh.....)
  • 1. Johnny Depp
    2. Hugh Laurie
    3. Robert Knepper
    4. Jonathan Rhys Meyers
    5. Shemar Moore
    6. Denzel Washington
    7. T.I.
    8. Robert Pattinson
    9. Wentworth Miller
    10. Simon Baker
    11. Jeffrey Donovan (Michael Weston on Burn Notice....sigh.....)
    12. Ty Pennington
  • 1. Johnny Depp
    2. Hugh Laurie
    3. Robert Knepper
    4. Jonathan Rhys Meyers
    5. Shemar Moore
    6. Denzel Washington
    7. T.I.
    8. Robert Pattinson
    9. Wentworth Miller
    10. Simon Baker
    11. Jeffrey Donovan (Michael Weston on Burn Notice....sigh.....)
    12. Ty Pennington
    13. David Boreanaz
  • 1. Johnny Depp
    2. Hugh Laurie
    3. Robert Knepper
    4. Jonathan Rhys Meyers
    5. Shemar Moore
    6. Denzel Washington
    7. T.I.
    8. Robert Pattinson
    9. Wentworth Miller
    10. Simon Baker
    11. Jeffrey Donovan (Michael Weston on Burn Notice....sigh.....)
    12. Ty Pennington
    13. David Boreanaz
    14. Taye Diggs