I did have fresh ground peanut and almond butter from the local Whole Foods market and that was much better than the natural I bought in the jar - do you have anywhere near you that can grind it fresh?
I love peanut butter, I eat a little every day. I wish I liked the natural better or that I was in the area of the Whole Foods more often...
There was a thread somewhere where Photo Chick talked about making her own nut butter in a food processor I think, I may see if I can find it...