Quote:
Originally Posted by Palestrina
What if it's not you that failed? What if it's dieting that's failed? We get these sorts of stories on this site on a daily basis. People think they fail at their diets but I really don't think that's true. Diets fail, they all fail. We really shouldn't need motivation to lose weight, nobody has more motivation to lose weight than an overweight person! It does not require motivation at all so quit trying to come up with inspiration everyday because there will always be good days, bad days, happy days, and frustrating days no matter how much you try to pump yourself up.
I'm not an expert on weightloss! I've only lost 20lbs in the last year. But unlike any other weightloss before that (the kind where you gain and lose and gain and lose) I've been able to keep it off. So far this is my largest triumph in weightloss, keeping it off!
There is a lot of evidence that the constant losing and regaining that dieters do is more harmful to our bodies and our metabolism than being steadily overweight. Most dieters sense this when they reminisce about how much easier it felt to lose weight in the past - that's because the more yoyoing you do the more your metabolism gets screwy and gets in the way of weightloss.
I guess what I'm trying to say is that you don't need to go on a strict diet to lose weight. In fact I think that diets are actually the cause of weight gain, especially regain!! It's not hard to witness since everyone I know who diets regains. Diets impose a volatile relationship with food which makes it hard to think clearly around food. This is especially evident in the low carb trend, the more you try to stay away from it the more likely you are to go back to it and fall into binges. Don't get me wrong, any weightloss I have I attribute to keeping my carb portions small! But you'll get nowhere if you ban this food or that food. Your body wants what you tell it it can't have, hence the binges!
Just be kind to yourself, there is no need to punish yourself over weight gain, food is not the enemy, and you've done nothing wrong! You might be eating for reasons other than hunger and that's ok, there are ways to calm that illusionary hunger and find a healthy relationship with food.
I pretty much disagree with everything said here.
Everyone needs to find the way of eating that works for them. It's not that diets fail, it is that some diets are harder to stick to than others AND people have triggers that make them not care about weight loss either temporarily or permanently.
In my opinion, weight loss is 90% in the head and 10% everything else. Those of us who are obese (not just a little pudgy, but really obese) didn't get that way simply by overeating. We saw our pants got tight and instead of eating less and moving more, we kept on eating and bought bigger pants. There were THINGS that made us not care about our size, our health and how we looked. NOT ALL OF US (some of it is medical) but MOST OF US.
And I 100% disagree about low carb dieting. It's not eating low carb that makes us want to binge on sugar, it's that something triggers us and we don't care about our weight/health and we give into sugar cravings and then just "give up". Not because of the diet, but because of our head being in a bad place. AND... those of us who have sugar/carb addictions (and it is real - believe me) find it extremely difficult to going back to low carb because we are addicted - like giving up cigarettes, then going back on.... that much harder to quit again.
And lastly, I have yo-yoed the last 3 years. I lost 90 pounds in 2011-2012, then from 2013 to now I have gained and lost over and over again - big chunks of weight either way. Now I'm going down again. Sure, Yo-yoing is not good for my body (but it is worse to say obese than to yo-yo) but it has absolutely NOT affected how fast I lose. Actually, I lose FASTER now because I know what works for me where the first time through I was still figuring that all out.
Now, I could blame my weight gain to my diet - if I can't keep it off, then something is wrong with how I'm eating, right? It's a conclusion that would be easy to leap to. But I also know it wasn't the diet. After YEARS of yo-yoing and trying different things with weight loss and eventually gaining, I have figured out that beyond my carb addiction I have SAD and one of my ways of coping with ALWAYS feeling sluggish and depressed is to medicate it with food. Not just any food, but high carb foods. And then I can't stop because of the addiction. 6 of the 8 times I've lost weight, I've gotten derailed during the winter months. And 1 of those remaining 8 times I got partially derailed and fought tooth and nail and was miserable. The ONLY time I have been able to stick to sane eating in winter was the winter of 2011 when I was basically told I was a health disaster and it shocked me into action (turns out it was 90% my thyroid).
So, I am returning to my plan of eating that works for me all months sans late octuber through early April. For those months I will go on an antidepressant and sit under a SAD light and see if it helps. Now that I'm AWARE of the trigger, I can work on not getting TRIGGERED!!! As during those months? I simply do not care - at all. I just want to eat and it feels good to eat - even though everything else feels awful.