Just gotta share this for all those other former Peanut Butter Cup addicts! I bought some peanut butter extract (Watkins brand, at Walmart), and added 1/2 tsp. to my chocolate pudding . . . SO good . I was afraid the extract might have a real artificial taste, but it doesn't at all. I seriously could close my eyes and pretend I was eating a partially melted Reese's

GlacierGirl3 - Yes, I am/was a Reeses' PB Cup addict (especially the mini unwrapped ones). Thank you for this tidbit of info. I'm headed to the store now - LOL. Jen

Thank you for sharing! So simple yet...brilliant! Those cups are my FAVE (and I haven't had one out of the kids halloween treats, yet I know exactly where they are! lol) I will be looking for a Watkins dealer ASAP.

brilliant!