Pumpkin butter

You're on Page 1 of 2
Go to
  • Does anyone enjoy it?
    OMG, I made some at home and I love it!
    I pour some on my protein pancake batter and also top Greek yogurt with it, DELISH!
  • I love it. I like to heat a couple of tablespoons in the microwave and then dip a ripe banana in it. I also like to put it on my roasted butternut squash.
  • Pumpkin butter sounds good, never had it. How do you make it?? I would love to try in greek yogurt or with a banana like you chicks suggested. Sometimes I open a can of natural pumpkin,add cinnamon and all spice and warm it up for a quick dessert or snack.
  • I was just drooling over this pumpkin butter recipe from Iowa Girl Eats.

    I don't have any pumpkin in the house or I would have made it this afternoon.
  • Heidi... Thanks for posting the link! It looks delish, and I will be making it soon
  • Quote: Pumpkin butter sounds good, never had it. How do you make it?? I would love to try in greek yogurt or with a banana like you chicks suggested. Sometimes I open a can of natural pumpkin,add cinnamon and all spice and warm it up for a quick dessert or snack.
    I just buy it. Trader Joe's has a yummy version that's reasonably inexpensive.
  • Love the recipe! Thank you for posting it.
  • Late to the party, but I love Pumpkin Butter. Also get mine at Trader Joe's, where, like everything they sell, it's seasonal and you gotta grab a few jars when it's available.

    DW puts just a dab on Delicata Squash when she roasts it - it's already really good and this addition makes it to-die-for.
  • Quote: .....DW puts just a dab on Delicata Squash when she roasts it - it's already really good and this addition makes it to-die-for.
    Mmmm! That sounds so good!
  • I love the pumpkin butter at trader joe's I really have to stock up when they bring it back later on this fall!
  • pumpkin butter?... Wow, never heard of it ... I love pumpkin though! How do you make it? Going to see if i can find the recipe
  • That sounds sooo good Suzan! Thanks for the tip!

    How do you make your protein pancake batter? I've looked a few recipes and they call for oats, but I don't know what kind! Do you think I could use steel cut oats? Any input appreciated!
  • Wow, guys, I had forgotten how much I love the pumpkin butter at Trader Joe's so wonderful, I'm a pumpkin freak, it really bummed me out when there was a shortage this year.
  • I love Trader Joe's pumpkin butter! Of course it's seasonal... so they don't have it right now the recipe looks good, though!

    I like eating a Tbsp or two stirred with some cinnamon and nutmeg in cooked oatmeal for breakfast!
  • Never had pumpkin butter- but I love everything pumpkin. Pumpkin pie, pumpkin bread, pumpkin pancakes...anything and everything.

    I'll definitely need the creative ways to cook pumpkins- I have two hills in my garden of sweet pie pumpkins for cooking. I also have a bunch more hills of decorative pumpkins as well- heehee.