I don't know if I am one of the people annoying you guys because I do post here, just by far not as much lately as when the challenge first started...and I did gain 0.8 of a lb this week. I have had a nice loss every other week of this challenge and used to post daily, several times a day actually. The past couple weeks things changed in our house because we are doing home rennovations and it's taking a lot of my time because I'm not naturally a home decorating type person so I'm slow at making decisions, and my children have been sick, and we have a ton of birthdays this month so I am getting out invitations, valentines, school parties, etc. SO I am not around mostly because I can't be...but I have been checking in whenever possible and trying to do personals when I can.
I think it is unfair to assume that if someone is not posting here they are not losing weight. I post religiously to a group in the 100 lb. forum, where I first started chatting here before this competition started. I am losing even while not getting to post here much, and I am posting over there becaus it is a smaller group who I have gotten to know more and feel more connected to, so I tend to go there daily for that support and to check up on people.
I was also checking here in the same way off and on through the day, but honestly almost none of my posts ever get a response. i don't expect everything I say to be responded to, and definitely never expect everyone to respond to anything..but when you post say 10 posts and not a single one is responded to, you wonder if you are just typing to yourself. I really felt ignored here, and like so many of you all know each other from previous challenges so you respond to each other and then other people, like myself, just kinda get pushed aside. Like I said, I don't expect every post to be responded to, but I'd say 98% of what I post is never responded to by a single person..and what is the point in talking to myself?
I do understand Rhonda's point about there not being pressure for personals...but if we're all posting about ourselves and few to none do personals, what is the point? that's not really communicating with others if we just post about ourselves. When this started I was doing personals, to almost every single post for our blue team and I liked doing it, but most of those were never responded to, and whatever I wrote about myself in those personals was usually never responded to, so I wondered if I was wasting my time.
I really see both sides of it. I don't want anyone pressured into personals, which is why I have said nothing about it and just started chatting more in the other forum again. But at the same time posting regularly and having almost everything you say ignored doesn't feel good either. Here's what i honestly have felt on this issue: seems the posts that get responses are when people are struggling and having a hard time...which is GREAT! I love that, but it sucks when posts reporting good progress are not responded to. I posted a 3.6 lb. loss and not a single person said a word back to me, for all 3 of my posts where I reported my loss for the group I might have gotten 1-2 responses total. But at the same time others were struggling and everyone was patting them on the back...I just felt my progress was ignored while we babied those who were gaining and that made no sense to me. I was trying to respond equally to those struggling and those doing great, but I felt I was really talking to myself here.
I do LOVE that we rally around those having problems and I try to do that as well...but hoenstly, ignoring those doing really well makes no sense. I am hard on myself and maybe hard on others, but I don't believe saying "oh it's okay, just get back to it" over and over to the same person accomplishes anything. I'm all for support but ten or more posts of "it's okay" to someone struggling doesn't help that person...there needs to be more of a kick in the butt and GET TO IT, and problem solving to help them get going again sometimes. I had a gain of 0.8 lb. this week and I have made a clear plan of how to FIX that and have started already. I am not going to say it's okay because it's not okay to me. anyway, my point is just that we can't ignore those doing well and just overly indulge those who gain. Those doing well get discouraged, or at least I did.
I know I am not the only person who feels this way...maybe I won't be the only one to speak out. I hope i'm not demonized and hate dnow, but you asked for honest opinions

and I am REALLY getting a lot out of this challenge. It has been very motivating for me, even without getting much support here (or at least I felt that way).

i don't want to be hated now for how I have felt in the group, if that makes sense.