Phat-I am 100% with you on buying cruelty free products. The last thing I used that was tested on animals was the oil of olay stuff, but that was more than a few years ago when it was still called oil of ulay and before I knew of the evils of procter and gamble and the many other pharmeceutical companies that make money from cruelty to animals. Since then I do my best to use only products that I know are cruelty free. I reserched this with my La Prairie and creme de la mer. My only concern is, in a cosmetics book I have it lists companies that do and do not test, however some references state that chanel do test on animals whilst I was told catergorically by a chanel SA that they dont. Same with dior. I have read that they do and then on a similar website that they dont. So in some respects it can be confusing. I know for a fact that brands such as L'oreal, max-factor, maybelline and cover girl ARE tested on animals and as such would never use these products regardless of how fantastic or rubbish they were. I am the same with household products. You won't find any persil, domestos, flash, fairy liquid or the like in my home. I use tesco's own range that is just as good but with a great no-animal testing policy. The co-op also have a really good policy.
As for Lush, I am a lush addict but their skincare was not for me. I tried the angels on bare skin, gorgeous, and some of their masks and my skin reacted horrible to them. The worst though was the lush handcream. My poor hands got covered in a huge red rash that was really dry and took weeks to go. I think I'll stick to the bath and shower stuff!
I had same outcomes with Dr H. I too bought those sample tins and my skin just did not like any of it! I ended up selling them on ebay!
It's only been in the past year or so that I have been using an eye cream. The first one I tried was an avon one but that just 'sat' under my eye and did nothing except make that are all greasy and felt really heavy even though I only used a small amount. I love that my La Prairie one sinks in right away and doesn't make my mascara run!
I like neals yard, but in terms of facial products a lot of essential oils are actually skin irritants, so I have to be careful with them.

