Julee-I have experience with OA another 12 step based program. Their emphasis was on not dieting, but in getting rid of our obsession with food. They considered it a victory if you had a better relationship with food, but never lost weight. I left when my group got taken over by bulimics and anorexics. I needed support, and it seemed like everyone else needed serious psychiatric help. I didn't actually join until I was in a maintenace phase, so I guess I didn't do it right from the get-go, so I don't know if it would have helped me lose weight or not. My main concern with yours is if you turn over control to someone else, how are you going to be able to maintain for life? Losing the weight is the easy part, maintaining is where I always fail. Extremes or all or nothing programs aren't healthy. We have to learn how to be healthy, and that usually means moderation in all things. One of the seven habits of successful maintainers is to expect some failures, but to never give up. Perfectionism is one of my biggest burdens. It helped to create the 600 pound monster I became, so I don't think perfectionism is going to help me get healthy. Listen to that little voice when something seems to extreme for you, and run the other direction.
I'm hurting today. My deep water aerobics instructed tried to drown up yesterday. It was the last day for several snowbirds who are heading north, and we won't have class on Friday because she has to go to staff meetings. She really wanted us to burn some calories to make it till Monday. My bottom half is so much more buoyant than my top half, that I have to fight extra hard against the water to stay upright. My butt always wants to bob to the surface. The regular water aerobics class isn't quite hard enough for me, and the deep water is a little too hard, so I am sticking with what is hard, not easy. That's a new sensation for me. I'm not the only one that struggles to keep up, and no one tries to makes me feel bad so I'm going to stick with it until my bottom half looks as good as my top half. Just getting myself there on time 3 days a week is a big change. Discipline is something I have never had when it comes to sticking to an exercise program. I'm actually looking forward to it. Everyone needs to find an exercise that they like well enough to look forward to. I can't wait until I can get up and down off the floor so I can start going to yoga or pilates classes. I still have to walk past the climbing wall to go to the locker room. That's going to be my celebration when I reach my goal weight. I'm going to have a party and climb the wall.

on the loss.

Forgot to think-you for adding me to the challenge
Crawl out of that bed! It is time to move it!
Now, if I just had the energy to follow through on that!
Way to go!
I wasn't one of them.......again. I swear I am going to
Is it helping yet?
ya bunches.