Avon has a really good one for a great price.

I put grapeseed or jojoba or almond oil (from NOW brand) on my eyes first, and rub it in a little. Then I get Neutrogena eyemakeup remover in the bottle and get that on a cotton pad and apply it. It usually takes two cotton pads. But we're talking about removing a lot of waterproof eyemakeup.

Coconut oil and olive oil are the only two things I use on my face and eyes at all. Takes makeup off, moisturizes after washing, and all natural. No chemicals, nothing irritating...makes skin happy.

Lancome regular one, or the Neutrogena one for a drugstore dupe.

I use cold cream - Pond's is the best, but usually any drugstore brand will do. Then I wash my face with Neutrogena Grapefruit cleanser.

If I need to remove waterproof mascara or gel eyeliner, I use baby oil. Gotta be careful not to get it in your eyes, tho!

I like the up & up (Target store brand) stuff in a bottle. Same stuff as Neutrogena but cheaper. I use goopy eyeliner and fake eyelashes w/glue and eyeshadow daily and it wipes it away almost effortlessly!

I use Sephora's brand of eye makeup remover. I don't need to rub or anything. It all just comes right off!