Quote:
Originally Posted by soxmanyxemotions
My family, friends and boyfriend always tell me they're afraid for my weight and my health, but they never help me.
I've finally discovered (after 40 years of dieting) that no one can help me. When they try, it usually backfires, because no matter what they say or do, it's usually the wrong thing.
My husband and I both had great dreams of being support to each other, as we both need to lose weight. As it turns out our needs are very different, and we can't help each other. When we try it backfires.
If we encourage each other to exercise, it feels like nagging.
If we're offered food by the other person, it feels like sabotage.
If we're not offered, or are criticised for a food choice, it feels like the other person is being food-cop.
If the other person lost more weight, we'd feel hurt and jealous (and there's no way for us to make sure we lose the same amount of weight each week).
In most cases, there is no possible way for the people living with you to provide just the right amount and kind of support. Just can't happen. Even with the best of intentions it tends to backfires. They'll never be able to do and say what you need, when you need it (especially since you may not always know what you need, when you need it).
I'd strongly recommend a TOPS (taking off pounds sensibly) if you can find one. It's cheaper than most weight loss groups. The national dues are $26 per year (and include a monthly magazine with success stories, tips, recipes...). Then you'll also pay local chapter dues (which are almost always under $5 per month. And there may be fines for weight gain (in one group I attended fines were a quarter no matter how much you gained, and in other groups fines were a dime per pound.
In most groups, you have ways to earn back some or all of the money you put into the group (and sometimes even more). The group I belong to runs so many weight loss contests, that a member could even make a profit. The group has a monthly white elephant auction that is entirely voluntary to participate in (I usually don't unless it's to donate something useless I have laying around the house). The auction money funds all of the many contests.
For example in our group if a person is the best loser for the month, they win $5. If they lose 10 and keep it off, at the end of the year they earn $5 for the 10 lb loss, and $1 for every month they keep it off (so if you lost 10 lbs in January and keep it off all year, you get $16 at the end of the year).
Many groups have ways to earn free monthly dues (in my last group, if you lost any weight in the previous month, even a quarter pound you got free dues for the next month).
I think the people living with you are too close to provide the best support. The best anyone living with you can do is stand out of your way (and some may not be able to even do that much).
Finding support outside your home (in my experience) works alot better.
You can always find reasons and excuses not to do things (and they'll always sound perfectly reasonable), but to actually accomplish anything you have to find ways to get things done.
And this isn't true about only weight loss. I've always said that if I didn't have to have a job I'd be able to finish my novel (the one I've been working on since 1991)
Five years ago I went onto disability, and my new excuse was "if I could sit in a chair for more than an hour, I could finish my novel."
Now that I can sit for more than an hour, I've decided I really need two or three.
If I had devoted 15 minutes every day to writing, I'd have finished several novels by now (I've vowed to finish a novel this year, but if I keep finding and using excuses, I will not).
The weight I've lost this time has been earned by small, easy, even lazy changes. You don't need to make huge changes, but you do have to make consistent ones. If starting big intimidates you, start small (but be ok with small results).
The biggest killer of weight loss is the fact that it's entirely normal to abandon the attempt. It's certainly normal, and almost a mandatory cultural tradition to get bored/frustrated and give up. You've got to choose to "rebel" a little and refuse to follow the normal (unsuccessful) path.