Quote:
Originally Posted by teapotdynamo
One thing I have to remind myself whenever I read articles like this is that, unfortunately, science is often (always?) informed by the culture in which it is practiced. While I do think we have a problem with weight/obesity in American culture, I have been skeptical for a while of the hysteria about an "epidemic," which I think often is colored by an irrational fear and disgust about fatness. Data used for these studies are usually sketchy at best -- for instance, one of the studies cited used only diabetic patients who lost weight -- not the best indicator of the overall population.
I think the "cutoff" for surgery at a BMI of 30 is appalling. In fact, I wonder if a lot of the "epidemic" talk about obesity could even be tracked to the exclusive use of BMI as a measure of overweight/obesity. I'm sure everybody here knows someone very athletic whose BMI is in the overweight range because of muscle mass. While WLS can save lives of people who are severely overweight, it just hasn't been practiced long enough or studied enough to warrant its use on a third of the U.S. population (who might not need it anyway)!
I think the general thrust of the article -- that it's damned difficult for most people to lose and keep off a substantial amount of weight (don't I know it) -- jells with what I've heard on here. But that said, I know from personal experience that even 30 pounds lost has made a huge difference to my physicial and emotional health. I know "fit and fat" is not the optimal place to be, but it sure beats fat and sedentary.
Quote:
Originally Posted by KO
and a word about language if I may
While words like epidemic and victim are quite popular in relating to obesity right now
they are downright wrong to use
Yes the #s of people who are obese have gone up
But I feel ( being a writer) the word epidemic leads people who are obese to feel they are helpless against a tirade of donuts or indeed adipous (i butchered that spelling) tissue
Hm...I was thinking about this over the weekend...whether the word 'epidemic' applies to the (pardon the pun) swelling numbers of obese people - especially children - that we see more and more often these days.
First off - let's start with the Webster's definition of "epidemic":
Quote:
1 : affecting or tending to affect a disproportionately large number of individuals within a population, community, or region at the same time <typhoid was epidemic>
2 a : excessively prevalent b : CONTAGIOUS 4 <epidemic laughter>
3 : of, relating to, or constituting an epidemic <the practice had reached epidemic proportions>
I'd say that using the Webster's definition, that the prevalance of obesity certainly does meet the standards of being an epidemic! (and recall that this year, Medicare started defining obesity as a disease, if you need that qualification to use the term 'epidemic'.)
Now, if you feel that using the word "epidemic" causes people to say, 'well, screw it - I'm just going to eat whatever I like because there's no hope' - maybe SOME people have that sort of defeatist attitude, but I would think that the use of the term 'epidemic' might make people SIT UP AND TAKE NOTICE. Remember when AIDS first became a newsmaker back in the early 1980's? (since I live in the San Francisco area, I might have heard about it earlier than folks who live outside this area) It seemed as though noone really sat up and paid attention until it was termed "the AIDS/HIV Epidemic". THEN people - affected or not - started doing something about it - researching new medications and treatments, educating the public about protecting themselves, etc.
And like the AIDS/HIV epidemic, or the campaign against tobacco, the focus needs to be on EDUCATION - and on the next generation - the children. It's well-known by now that fat kids all too often grow up to be fat adults - yet, I still hear parents say "oh, they're just kids - they can eat whatever they want, that's just baby fat". The thing is - many of these kids are eating adult-sized portions of food and NOT exercising. When I was a kid, I spent my afternoons after school playing outside in the yard on the swingset, or playing hide and seek or kickball with my sisters and the other kids in the neighborhood. The streets were FILLED with kids riding bikes, skating, going to the parks, etc. These days - the streets are empty and the kids are all inside the house, watching TV or playing videogames...often eating at the same time.
I don't need a study to tell me that there are more obese people - and specifically obese children - today than there were when I was a child. All I have to do is go to the mall, or McD's, or tag along with my sister when she picks up her two kids from school, a birthday party, or a dance to see the proof right in front of me.
Whatever word you want to use - epidemic, outbreak, eruption, rash - it's a sign that SOMETHING needs to be done, and we need to start with the next generation in mind!