So I bought this dress today and I'm not sure if I should keep it or return it. I generally like it,but have a couple of issues. 1)I already have a few black dresses 2)it's a size 4 and I think that might be the only reason I got it.

It feels comfortable, bit it's also the kind of dress that will be unforgiving if I gain any weight. So let me know what you think. And please be honest. Also, since you can't see the bottom of the dress, it's about knee length, just past them.

i think it looks good! Honestly! and you have a great figure!

It looks great!

I'm a shortie short, so I say NO to anything that is a little past knee length (or I take it to the tailor if it is that cute). But anything at or past knee length makes me look more short and squabbly like a hobbit. But that's just me, and I am very sensitive to hobbit jokes.

Very classic and cute!

It looks great on you! And it'll be a great incentive to maintain your weight, because you'll be turning heads whenever you wear that out!

It's a cute shape and I can see why you love it but it looks too small. I think it's probably actually ruching but the effect is that it looks like the dress is too tight and pulling. You're TEENY, there's no reason for you to wear dress that makes you look like you're wearing size too small.

I agree it looks a little tight. I can see ur belly button in it. But it just might be that kinda material.
I also agree you have such a cute shape.

Yes, it is classic and cute. Good job on your weight loss! You look wonderful!!!!!

i second this opinion

I think it looks great. Where did you get it, I want one

I think it looks great ! To me it appears to fit perfectly.

It looks great! You have such a tiny waist I'm jealous! It's looks a little tight but if it's comfy then I don't see a problem just don't wear it if you get bloated.

It looks awesome on you! Wear it!

It looks too tight across your stomach. I think something belted or gathered at the smallest part of your waist that doesn't cling would suit your shape better. You have a really nice hourglass thing going on!

Thanks for the input soon far! For the person who asked where I got it, it was on clearance at Target. Only $8. I think I would have liked it better in a 6, but they only had 2,4,10,&14.