3 Fat Chicks on a Diet Weight Loss Community

3 Fat Chicks on a Diet Weight Loss Community (https://www.3fatchicks.com/forum/)
-   Exercise Equipment (https://www.3fatchicks.com/forum/exercise-equipment-213/)
-   -   Ellipticals (https://www.3fatchicks.com/forum/exercise-equipment/101017-ellipticals.html)

Suzanne 3FC 01-02-2007 06:07 PM

Ellipticals
 
Do you own an elliptical? If so, please let us know what you think of it. Does it work well for you? Have you had any problems with it? What brand and model is it?

Thanks :)

Suzanne 3FC 01-02-2007 09:07 PM

I have a New Balance 8.0 Elliptical and I HATE it. I wanted the 9.0, which has the wheel in the front and the style feels better on my legs. Unfortunately, they only ship it by freight and a freight truck can't get into my neighborhood. So I got the 8.0 since it could be shipped by UPS. The wheel is in the back. I thought I'd get used to it, but I never did. I haven't used it in 2 years. That was the worst purchase I've ever made. I should have just shopped locally and spent a little more money instead of trying to save money online.

nelie 01-03-2007 11:21 AM

I have the Lifefitness X5i and I love love love that machine.

I tested many ellipticals and I wanted something that felt stable and was built well. I tested over 20 ellipticals in stores and looked at all the features and warranties. I liked the Precors but was really unimpressed with their lack of features in their low end ellipticals. The Lifefitness really packed a lot of features in their ellipticals.

I really enjoy the heart rate programs on my elliptical. I never enjoyed heart rate programs in the gym because I always thought that the heart rate was off. My elliptical came with a heart rate body strap which I put just under my breast. Apparently a heart rate body strap is more accurate than heart rate taken through the palms. Overall, I think it has 16 programs total? Although there are a few programs I really enjoy, I do the other programs as well to add variety.

My elliptical also has an adjustable stride which is an interesting feature. I believe the adjustable stride helps work different muscle areas as it simulates different motions. The shortest stride is supposed to simulate walking while the longest stride is supposed to simulate running. The stride lengths go from 18" to 24". I like mixing it up by changing the strides once in a while.

It is pretty quiet as well. For a while, I was doing the elliptical while DH slept and he said it would never wake him. The only thing that would wake him was the beeping in setting up a program. Luckily, the elliptical is able to set 4 preset programs so all you do is select it and go. Otherwise I'd have to set my age, weight and level each time I workout. I usually keep one of the preset programs as a rotating program which basically has my weight and age stored, then I tell it which program to use.

One of the major drawbacks is that it is 7 feet long. So DH and I had to do some major planning when purchasing it. We purchased it from a store that offered delivery for $150 and they carried it up 4 flights of stairs and assembled it for us. For a machine that weighs over 200 lbs, the $150 was well spent.

I think it is one of the best ellipticals I've ever used, in or out of a gym. I really wasn't interested in getting a Life Fitness when I went looking for an elliptical. In fact, it was the last machine I tried because I specifically told the sales person that I didn't want a Life Fitness. He told me that I didn't have to buy it but that I should at least try it. So I did and DH tried it. We both admitted it was the best elliptical we tried in our price range and that is what sold us on it.

Celestyna 01-04-2007 10:22 PM

I bought the Champion C44F elliptical from Sears. It was originally a 799.00 unit but it was priced down to 299.00 for the holidays and to bring in the new model Champion has out in that range. I LOVE it. Every other one I tried for under $600 was waaaay rickity. I noticed, though, a weird sound every once in a while on one of the rollers that happens like every other workout for a few minutes. I lubed it up well. The unit's base is huuuge and it took me for-freaking-EVER to assemble it, but after three glasses of wine and four hours, I had that puppy ready to go, computer system and all.

I have to break it back down to go in my "exercise room", I might investigate the problem with the sound. It's actually almost soundless however and has a calorie readout that i know you're not supposed to trust those things, but i indulge myself. I get in an hour a day now for the past week about twice or three times a day. It has a book stand. I read and sometimes plug my ipod into it.

Gadgets! just can't live without them. My rear end has been looking tight and happy this week because of it.

Lilion 01-05-2007 11:30 AM

We got our elliptical from Sears and, from looking at the website, I believe it is the ProForm XP Elliptical, ProForm XP 115. We paid close to $500 for it...not too bad as exercise equipment goes but it's about $100 cheaper now. It is fairly compact for an elliptical and although I haven't tried, I'm sure I could get it thru a door easily enough. I think it has four personal trainer programs and you can program it yourself to some extent. I haven't tried any of the programs yet as I've just started really using it three weeks ago. (yeah, we've had it for MONTHS) The stride is also adjustable, which is nice. It it seems quite sturdy, is easy enough to move when we need to, and is a good workout. It does have an odd squeak, but that's what you get when you go for a cheaper model. All the same, I'm pleased with it.

UPDATE: When I did my earlier post I had only been using the elliptical faithfully 3 weeks. Another month later and I'm still using it. I have now tried the persoanal trainer programs. It has 2, 20 minutes ones and 2, 30 minute ones. They give a good workout. It has developed a couple of annoying noises. The display also runs on batteries and they die after about 2 months. All the same, I'm still glad we bought it, but after reflection, when this one dies I think I'll talk DH into one of the gym-quality ones. You get what you pay for.

SlimLindy 01-11-2007 02:15 PM

I have a Precor EFX. I forget which model. I was expensive (maybe $1500-$2000?) but I don't remember exactly. I've had it for over three years now, and used it for an hour a day, often twice a day, nearly every day. I LOVE LOVE LOVE it. It doesn't have a ton of features (no heart rate monitor), and it is big (it's in our garage, along with a little TV for me!). The features it has: electronic readout with time, number of strides, strides per minute, and calories burned; height adjustment; resistance adjustment. You can raise and lower it (which I do... I start out with it in mid-range for a five minute warm up, then do the rest of the hour at the highest height it offers). You can increase resistance (from 1 to 20, but it is literally impossible for me to do anything at the highest levels). It is strong, steady, quiet, and not even remotely rickety. As solid as they make them. Seriously well worth the money for how much it gets used. If you know you'll use it, DEFINITELY go for the higher end machines. I chose mine with a minimum of added features because I had used ellipticals a lot and never wanted to use the programs or features. There are other models with programs and such.

Mami 01-15-2007 12:06 PM

Ellipticals
 
Please give me reviews on your home elliptical machines. I'm about to purchase an elliptical and want to be sure to avoid the bad ones, so I'd really appreciate it if you'd tell me about yours.

Meg 01-15-2007 12:18 PM

Mami - I'm going to merge your post in with the current thread about ellipticals so that everyone's on the same page. :)

phatgirl 01-15-2007 05:27 PM

I just purchased a Vision elliptical. 6200HRT and I love it! It's quiet, sturdy, and gives a great workout. There are many different programs and the programs adjust according to your target heart rate.

The one thing I don't like is that it doesn't have a mini-countdown. Some ellipticals have a mode where you can see how long you will be at a specific resistance (if you are doing hills). Minor but I would like to have that.

Also, it does take up a lot of space and though one of the selling points is is that it folds, I do not fold it. It's HUGE and folding it doesn't do me much good. It's not like a flimsy gazelle so you can't stick it under your bed. It's a hardcore piece of equipment that is gym-quality.

The cost was 1699+tax so it ended up being around 1800 dollars. I hope I continue to use it! It's so convenient.

Mami 01-16-2007 09:07 PM

Has anyone tried the Keys Fitness Center G elliptical? It seems to be one of the few that is relatively small for being a heavy duty machine (the area needed to use the machine is 67" in length/35 width). The stride length is adjustable from 17" to 25", which I thought was a really good feature to be able to adjust the workout and use the length that feels comfortable for my height. I think the machine is fairly new, so I haven't seen too much about it. I really liked the feel of it in the store, but I'm just hesitant because I don't know its track record and it is quite pricey. Any ideas? Anyone see this company or model in consumer reports? Thanks :)

nelie 01-17-2007 02:11 PM

Mami, Never heard of them and I couldn't find reviews of them on the review sites I used for my elliptical. Epinions did have some user reviews:

http://www0.epinions.com/Keys_Fitnes...ptical_Trainer

Another elliptical that you may be interested in if you are looking for a small footprint is Octane. DH and I really liked one of the Octane ellipticals when we were trying ellipticals out.

Mami 01-17-2007 09:12 PM

Nelie, thanks a lot for the link to the reviews. I really liked the feel of the Keys Center G when I tried it in the store. The Keys Center G is a new model with a different system (there is no front or back wheel), so I'm a bit hesitant. Apparently it was runner up for some equipment award and all the reviews I've read have been favorable (except one because there was a noise). The 2007 model has an electronically changeable stride, from 17" to 25", which I really liked since I'm 5'2" and DH is 6'3". Not that he has any reason to use it as he is ultra slim. And space is definitely an issue, the other high quality models are just too long for my space. I want to get it but just being cautious given the expenditure. Cant wait!

nelie 01-17-2007 09:24 PM

The octane one we looked at had an electronic changeable stride and I believe it took less space than the Keys center G one but I may be mistaken. It is probably in a similar price range as well. I really like the adjustable stride on my elliptical.

I understand caution. It does look like the Keys one has a pretty good warranty as well and that is pretty critical when it comes to ellipticals. I know someone who has a Precor that is fairly new (couple months old) and it is already making weird noises. Luckily it came with a good warranty so they can get it looked at.

Mami 01-18-2007 08:13 AM

I will definitely look into the Octane Nelie. It's hard to find many stores that have a bunch of ellipticals on the floor; I'll start looking on the internet but its so critical to try it out first since they all have such a different feel. Any recollection which store you saw the Octane? Thanks!

nelie 01-18-2007 09:34 AM

Well I definitely recommend trying out as many ellipticals as you can before you actually purchase one. Look for sporting good stores and fitness equipment stores and see what they have. We saw the Octane at a place called "Fitness Resource" and they had probably 15 different brands of ellipticals. We also visited a place called "Leisure Fitness" and they also seemed to have around 15 brands of ellipticals although they seemed to specialize in Precors. These may be local places though so I'm not sure if they would have something near you.

Our elliptical search started at Sears, then to Dick's Sporting goods but then we decided we should visit stores that actually specialize in fitness equipment.

Mami 01-18-2007 01:25 PM

LOL, I guess I'm following in your footsteps Nelie! I started at Sears and Sports Authority, only to realize the machines were, to be polite, not that great. I found the Keys Center G at Leisure Fitness, but no Octane there. Not sure about Fitness Resource but will check it out. Its hard to find the specialty stores using google for some reason. Let me know if you know of any other stores that have a chain in north NJ or NY. Thanks a lot.

Diva 07-21-2007 09:21 AM

I have never used one but I see peeps in the Exercise acountability thread using them ALL the time. I want one for Christmas but our price range can't go over $300 and that is pushing it. What I have gathered from this thread is that one @ that range will be a piece of crap. Is this true? Maybe I should look more into a treadmill or Gizelle? I had a Gizelle before for $100 and used it for 6 months and really enjoyed it and saw results but had to sell it because at the time I needed some money. :(

Also, i asked this in the aboved mentioned thread and haven't gotten an answer, but, do elliptical's aid in shaping ones booty? I have a wide flat behind and am looking to J-Lo it up some. Do these do that? At all?

Ethereal 07-21-2007 12:42 PM

Originally Posted by Diva:
Also, i asked this in the aboved mentioned thread and haven't gotten an answer, but, do elliptical's aid in shaping ones booty? I have a wide flat behind and am looking to J-Lo it up some. Do these do that? At all?

I've been researching ellipticals also, and it sounds like ones that allow inclines will work the booty and other body parts nicely. Make sure to look for that option while you're shopping.

I found this great article the other day:

http://www.ellipticaltrainers.com/in...l_ratings.html

Also check out the links on the left - there's an elliptical buying guide and here is their list of "Best Buys" for 2006. There are also a couple of other interesting articles.

After review, this is the one I'm considering:

http://www.smoothfitness.com/ellipti...ooth-ce-32.htm

Diva 07-21-2007 04:10 PM

Ethereal, Thank you very much. Those are pretty pricey, but upon reading about these, the pricey opnes are the better ones. I will be working soon and that'll be feasable soon. I am thinking I want a gazelle again too, but I want upgrade on that. Thanks for answering. maybe one day I'll have a good butt, lol!
Oh, I also liked the art too! :)

L144S 08-23-2007 07:29 PM

i have a precore, I have had t for about 8 years and it still works great. I have had to service it once in all that time, i admit I use it more in the winter because I prefer to walk, as does the dog :)
My advice is to get the best you can afford.

carolr3639 08-24-2007 10:48 AM

We have a Reebok RL 1500 and it is great. I'm not very mechanical but it gets me breathing hard and sweating in 5 min. And it says you burn 250 cal in 25 min. You can burn more if you go faster. That's far better than walking. It is very quiet and smooth and reminds me of a fair ride. It does make my thighs burn at first but doesn't hurt otherwise. My DH tried out a lot of different ones and looked all over the internet. We paid about $1000. It doesn't have to be plugged in either.

Just Deb 08-28-2007 01:18 PM

Diva - I have had both a gazelle and an elliptical. I think it is a much better workout on the elliptical. And yes it will change the shape of your whole body. More curves.

NoVaVTFan 08-28-2007 07:50 PM

I bought an Eclipse 1100HR elliptical in March. I got it o about $330 from Dicks Sporting Goods. I looked around a lot and did as much research as possible before deciding on the Eclipse. Most of the reviews I read from people online said that it was a reliable machine for the small amount of money you pay for it compared to the Precor or other large machines.

I like it because it has different inclines, and 12 programs to choose from if you don't want to set a manual program. I feel like I get a good workout on it - it does make a few weird creaks sometimes, but I think that's probably because it is a cheaper machine. I don't feel like it will fall apart, and it feels stable and sturdy enough for moderate exercise.

kathy4804 08-31-2007 02:17 AM

Well I didn't have much money to waste so i purchased my elliptical machine at walmart for like 168 plus tax but it works ! OMG i LOVE it . I wish i would have bought it sooner . I've been using it for 2 days now and i already lost 2lbs. I use it 20 - 30 min. a day. I dont regret buying it !

blznbloomers 11-13-2007 11:45 PM

Ellipticalls
 
Kathy4804: I to got mine at wal-mart. I love mine as well. I looked and looked online and in stores galore for a smart-easy-affordable-butt_rounding piece of equipment. Finally I had the sportsman associate to get the display down for me at wal-mart and I tried it for a while and liked it, but thought about the price. I figured since it was only $168.00 that it may not be what I was looking for to get in shape. After about 3 days of searching in sears and dicks sporting goods, I thought "what the heck, $168.00 is well worth the price. If I dont; like it, then I can sale it at a garage sale. Well after 2 years of using it and developing this tight firm hiney. My cheap walmart ellipticall isnt leaving my house for no reason. It is the most wonderful thing. I put it in front of my tv at 11:30am ( young and the restless) and ride it until the second commercial. After the commercial is over, back to the riding, then at 12:00 take another break at drink a bottle of water. From 12:00 till 12:30 I ride non stop. I may be 36 and over wieght, but I got a firm butt and smaller hips......

just get it done 01-18-2008 09:54 PM

We just purchased the Horizon e900 and I just love it. We got it for 999.00 and the orignal price was over 2000. It took us over 2 hours to put it together . My husband was impressed with the packaging. The instructions had everything broken down in steps and all the nuts and bolts were packaged separtely for each step. It also included all the tools you need to put it together . Everything works great on it and we just love it.

VermontMom 01-20-2008 08:12 PM

My husband bought a Sears Pro-Form 15.5 s for Christmas. I'm the only one whose used it so far :dizzy:

I haven't been on any other ellipticals, but I think this one isn't quite a high quality model. It feels a little rickety, and it can squeak pretty annoyingly. But I'm still using it :carrot:

mandyleigh 01-24-2008 11:12 PM

I just bought the Nordictrack ASR 1000. I've only had it for two days, but so far i LOVE it!!! It has many different resistance levels AND it has a power incline ramp...which to me is the best part!! This one was 899 on sale at Sears, but seems to be well worth the price so far!

bambifox 01-27-2008 08:41 AM

I use the lifefitness eliptical...it's the best you can buy, smooth range of motion and all the options...but a bit pricey...over $1600, but worth it in the long run because of the quality of construction...but the Octane is not far behind in price, but not as smooth a ride and construction not as good. Hope this helps...Joyce

See Spot Shrink 02-01-2008 11:01 PM

I covet the Smooth CE 7.4 elliptical. They only sell them online, direct from the manufacturer. It'll be about $2200 with shipping and "white glove" service, where they bring it in and set it up for you.

I'm getting one as my reward for getting to the halfway mark. "Only" 46.5 lbs. to go! :D

jvblackxj 01-11-2010 10:59 PM

Originally Posted by Celestyna:
I bought the Champion C44F elliptical from Sears...

Do you still have this elliptical. I am desperately trying to find the AC Adapter information. If you could tell me the voltage and possibly the Amperage (usually something like 300mA or 800mA or even 1A).

Please PM me

It would be very much appreciated.

MotoMichelle 02-05-2010 11:54 AM

We recently bought a Schwinn 420 elliptical and like it a lot. I have a gym membership and also do a lot of other cardio besides elliptical, so I wasn't looking for an elliptical with tons of features.

This one fit the bill and the price was right at $600. There are a few programs on it as well as the heart rate pads. You can increase the amount of resistance, however you can't change the incline.

It is sturdy, well built, and VERY quiet. We also have a Schwinn recumbent bike that is extremely quiet as well. That's nice to have in the house. It also has a small footprint at only about 5 ft long.

It may not have all the fancy bells and whistles, but does deliver on a good, sweaty workout especially when you up the resistance.

Here's a picture of ours:

http://teaatdusk.com/wp-content/uplo...Tcomplete1.jpg


And a size comparassion to our bike:

http://teaatdusk.com/wp-content/uplo...01/bikeET1.jpg


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:19 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.