3 Fat Chicks on a Diet Weight Loss Community

3 Fat Chicks on a Diet Weight Loss Community (https://www.3fatchicks.com/forum/)
-   Does it Work? (https://www.3fatchicks.com/forum/does-work-11/)
-   -   Do you count on Amazon customer reviews to help you choose diet products? (https://www.3fatchicks.com/forum/does-work/241449-do-you-count-amazon-customer-reviews-help-you-choose-diet-products.html)

Suzanne 3FC 08-22-2011 04:21 PM

Do you count on Amazon customer reviews to help you choose diet products?
Can Amazon product reviews help you find a diet pill that works? Sadly, many are paid reviews that are not true.

When I buy anything on Amazon, I count on the customer reviews to help steer me in the right direction. For the most part, the reviewers are honest and unbiased. I enjoy reviewing everything from food to books to electronics.

I've often wondered about the reviews I've read of certain diet products because I knew that research had proven them ineffective. Why would anyone provide a positive review of something that other customers swear was useless or made them ill, and there is no research to back up the claims? Could it be the placebo effect?

As it turns out, there are companies out there that pay for reviews on Amazon. You can make about $2 for every review you post, and you do not need to even purchase the product. Many of these reviews come from other countries, with fake Amazon accounts. The reviewers are hired by a firm that is hired by the manufacturers to promote their products.

Amazon is not responsible for this. There are special websites that hire freelance writers, and some of them post jobs for Amazon reviewers. Amazon has no way of knowing which reviews are paid so they can't do anything about it. Some reviews are marked "verified Amazon purchase", but that also doesn't help because the reviewers are given promo codes to get the product free.

If you consider diet products and feel swayed by published reviews, please be suspicious before you make the purchase. Find the list of ingredients and go to websites such as WebMD and search for info on those ingredients.

tbills 10-24-2011 01:57 PM

I do my research
No I do not, and I'm glad to be here the site is grea. I do my reseach and this is a site I found to do my best and figure things out for me

kaplods 10-24-2011 09:29 PM

For all amazon book and product reviews, I always read the negative reviews with the most interest. I'm more likely to buy a product with a few negative reviews than only rave reviews, because the negative comments usually provide the most information (the "weakness" one person may describe may actually be something I'm looking for, or not concerned with).

It does annoy me though when the review isn't of the product itself, but of the seller.

sensualappeal 11-07-2011 05:33 PM

Wow, I had no idea people get paid to write reviews. I mean, I KNEW it's what people do but I guess it just never really clicked. I certianly do look at the negative reviews first though before looking at the good ones. I mean, it does always look fishy if a review includes ALL great positive things about a product and none bad - there usually are side effects, especially when it comes to diet pills. But this is an eye opening post, thanks!

Dagny18 11-28-2011 06:01 PM

I do read reviews on Amazon.com even if I am going to buy the item in a different store. Sometimes I even read them after I have bought a product, and these are for motivational purposes to see what results I might expect.
Now, things I buy are not things like pills and such but usually exercise products, dvds, equipment, ect. I try to decide if the item might be in my fitness range and not too difficult or easy for me. If it is exercise for inside, I try to gather information on how much space I might need to use this product or dvd. If I will be jumping up and down alot and might not have the room for it. If it is a dvd, I will read the reviews as well as try to find youtube trailers of scenes from it.
Typically I read reviews for dvds, sports equipment like bikes ect (though I have not bought one yet) and I just bought a heart rate monitor and was reading reviews on it.
I have bought a Total Gym at Kmart and spent almost a year researching it before buying it. It is the most expensive item I have bought to date, and was definitely not a spure of them moment purchase.

bargoo 11-28-2011 06:28 PM

I once received really bad service , and and equally bad attitude at a pharmacy over a prescription they had lost, misplaced or maybe never filled .
This store had a suggestion box, I filled out a complaint, name,date, everything and put it in the box. I never received any kind of a response . I believe they throw out the negative comments and only forward the good comments to the home office. Don't know for sure but it looks that way to me.

grabec 01-11-2012 07:47 PM

I love Amazon reviews and wish a lot of other places that sell things had them. It is so helpful to read other's experiences with different products, books etc I too did not know you could get paid to write a review but that is ok as long as you are not directed as to how to slant your review.

Taheetee 05-30-2012 04:48 AM

I refuse to buy off of Amazon, but I do find the reviews helpful and I look for patterns in the negative ones. I've never looked at it for diet pills though...I did look at it for reviews on a shake from a popular program recently, and was surprised at the number of positive reviews (usually it's a pretty well split between positive and negative) but a few extra clicks revealed that reps for the program were writing the raves. Sick that some people are actually paid to do that!

drixnot 07-16-2012 06:37 PM

lol... I'm cheap. I don't buy ANY weight loss products. I don't believe in magic pills. If such a thing existed it would only be available by prescription and I wouldn't be able to afford it.

Espressowhip 01-23-2013 02:08 PM

When I look at any product I (usually) only look at the negative reviews. For most products, I found that I need to be discerning.

Some reviewers are looking for diet products that allow them to eat cheeseburgers and see weight loss, and are disappointed. Others will claim to eat right and exercise with no results. If you eat right and exercise, it's science, you'll lose something. These two types of reviews aren't helpful.

Sometimes the positive reviews will list pros and cons, these are the most helpful.

Right now I'm looking at something recommended by Dr.Oz. Turns out it's far from a new product, and being marketed under a new branding. The only new thing about it is some newer research findings...and the most interesting weight loss benefits are a theoretical, rather than sound clinical trial based results.

newmommy5112 02-13-2013 08:47 PM

aw man, i count on those :(

blessedfly1 03-16-2013 09:46 PM

As a favorite Amazon customer, Yes I do pay attention to review. I kinda see the difference in the good and bad reviews. If there is a lot of reviews, and most of the reviews are good and just few bad, then I may purchase it. I also don't make a habit of purchasing things that Amazon don't stand by, that's because if Amazon sells it and something go wrong, Amazon will put the money right back in your bank account.

splendidtree 07-23-2017 03:44 PM

I take into account all reviews and try to remember everyone is different. Also fakespot helps me to find which products are perhaps..well..fake? lol

EmmaWhite 09-29-2017 07:39 AM

It's better to search for alternative sites without add's and paid reviews...

clem24 10-31-2017 05:13 AM

Yea, why not? There are some honest reviews

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:18 AM.

Copyright 2018 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.