Thread Tools
Old 01-20-2014, 07:48 PM   #1  
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2014
Posts: 3

Smile Calling low-carb experts, for better or worse!

Hi, Ladies

First time poster here. Life-long dieter, ho-ho. (losing the same 30-35 pounds over and over but at least not gaining more every time...)

So with the new year I decided it was back to Weight Watchers for me. I'm nearing my 50th birthday and really didn't like the way things were trending. it's been a few years since i have done anything about it, so I figured it was time.

A little background: When I was in high school, I did low-carb (probably similar to classic Atkins). I lost weight very quickly but was a maniac about carbs ever after. It really seemed to create a lifelong hunger for carbs.

As a grownup, I have lost weight successfully on WW three times. The first two times were before the Points Plus program. The third time it was murder to take the weight off (I did keep 10 pounds off for many years). But there was just something about the PointsPlus that did not seem to click with me. The Simply Filling does not click, either, as I don't do fat-free dairy. I just don't.

Fast forward to the beginning of 2014. I started WW at the beginning of Jan, track using PointsPlus. Well, today's weigh-in really sucked wind. I was actually UP a pound from my starting weight two weeks ago. You have got to be kidding me. And I was very compliant.

Today I bought "The Calorie Myth" at the bookstore. Hot new book. I've read the first few chapters. The guy's premise is that years of eating high-carb (he calls it high-starch/sugar) foods throws off the hormones that control the body's ability to burn fat, leading to boosted set points (higher weights) that the body fights to maintain. By changing over to what he calls "high-quality" foods (basically protein and quality fats), he says, we can lower our set points regardless of quantity of food eaten and voila maintain a lower weight for life.

I must tell you I am automatically suspicious of anything that differentiates the quality of one food to another, but he has included a lot of science that seems to make sense. Given how badly things are going for me on WW, I'm going to reserve judgment and try his five-week program.

I am pretty worried about my ability to stick to low carb over the long haul given my past experience with it. He makes a huge deal out of not having to go hungry, and after two weeks of 1,200-calorie days, I'm inclined to agree. But over the long term??? Wasn't it established years ago that it is virtually impossible to stick to low carb forever?? He really glosses over this part, says your appetites will change. Hmmm.

What do you think? Anyone have experience with this fairly-new book and author??


172/173/150 (possibly 140 if things go well!!)
legg3819 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-20-2014, 08:14 PM   #2  
*Shakes fist at regain*
crispin's Avatar
Join Date: May 2013
Location: U.S.
Posts: 375

S/C/G: 150ish/ 114 / 109

Height: 5'


I'm no expert, but my first question is how low carb are we talking? I've been eating lowish carb for a few years now, and I'll probably keep eating this way for life. I usually eat 50 - 150 grams of carbs a day. I stick to the lower end when I'm trying to drop a few pounds. That's probably not low carb, but it is lower than I had been eating all my life, and is lower than the average American eats. I'm comfortable and satisfied with this amount.

Last edited by crispin; 01-20-2014 at 09:27 PM.
crispin is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-20-2014, 08:21 PM   #3  
Senior Member
Mad Donnelly's Avatar
Join Date: Oct 2013
Posts: 259

S/C/G: 212/156/145

Height: 5' 4"


I think it's impossible to stick to low fat forever. I'll be honest, I can't tell you long term; but I know I can't go back to eating grains and sugars. I may wish I could but I can't change the properties of sugar and grains that play havoc on our bodies. So giving it up it must be. I wish to rid my stomach of its visceral fat and sugars and grains work against that. No more all pasta dinners or all cereal breakfast which will only fill me up for a short time. But while I wish to keep my hunger abated, I am also not scared of hunger anymore. It's not a crisis to be filled with a binge on sugary baked goods which it used to be.
Mad Donnelly is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-20-2014, 09:44 PM   #4  
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2014
Posts: 3


Hmm I like your thoughts, thank you. Oh, I absolutely would not be able to sustain low fat forever, nor do I think that is in any way desirable. I suppose that is the crux of why calories don't matter -- these nutrient-rich foods (read high-cal) are actually the most desirable ones.
legg3819 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-20-2014, 10:01 PM   #5  
Senior Member
freelancemomma's Avatar
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Toronto
Posts: 2,213

S/C/G: 195/145/145

Height: 5'11"


No doubt the low-carbers will all chime in with their support. To me the book sounds like just one more cog in the revolving wheel of diet books and theories. I don't believe in the set point notion to begin with -- I'm with those who posit a lifestyle "settling point" instead -- and nothing in my personal eating or dieting experience gives me any reason to vilify carbs.

freelancemomma is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-20-2014, 10:03 PM   #6  
Senior Member
Jacqui_D's Avatar
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Ohio, USA
Posts: 4,508

S/C/G: 188/185/164

Height: 5'8"


I am doing a modified Slow Carb Diet, and for 6 days a week, it's low carb, but the 7th day is a cheat day when I can have anything I want. That's how I am able to stick with it without a problem. It's not for everyone though. Some people are triggered by a cheat day. For the plan to work, you absolutely must go back to low carb on the non-cheat days; otherwise, you're just cheating all the time rather than lowering your overall carb intake.
Jacqui_D is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-20-2014, 11:01 PM   #7  
Embracing the suck
JohnP's Avatar
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: California - East Bay
Posts: 3,185

S/C/G: 300/234/abs

Height: 6'9"


Originally Posted by legg3819 View Post
I must tell you I am automatically suspicious of anything that differentiates the quality of one food to another, but he has included a lot of science that seems to make sense.
I didn't read the book and you may be representing his premise but rest assured our bodies do not lose the ability to burn fat for fuel and I have no idea what you mean by quality of food.

Calories dictate fat loss or gain.
JohnP is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-20-2014, 11:07 PM   #8  
Posts: n/a


Haven't read or even heard of the book till now. But it does kind of dovetail with my experiences the past 9 months.

I am not on Atkins but I cut out wheat and most grains. Snacks, chips, fast food etc. The weight has really come off my belly. But also I've noticed my carb metabolism has changed as has my overall metabolism.

If I do say have a carb heavy meal now I am not famished soon after like before. I can only assume my body not flooded daily with carbs can now process them better when I have the occasional high carb meal.

Also went for 10 days to in-laws over Xmas with some side travel. Exercised less and eat out a lot. Did have some healthy meals but day to day was much worse than my at home routine. Especially driving back was bad. Only gained like half a pound. So my metabolism has seemed to change a lot.

And my cravings for carb, especially bread and pasta keeps going down not up. Wheat is almost repulsive to me now.

I have never heard anything about low carb being hard to stick with long term. Fat and protein are pretty satiating and tasty.

Last edited by diamondgeog; 01-20-2014 at 11:12 PM.
  Reply With Quote
Old 01-21-2014, 03:23 AM   #9  
Senior Member
sarahinparis's Avatar
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Paris, France
Posts: 757

S/C/G: 235 / 189 / 165


There are lots of people who adjust to permanently changing their eating habits to maintain a loss. Sound like you have never mastered that skill on any program so I think if I were you I'd spend time reading and planning for maintenance (of a low-carb, lower-carb or traditional low fat diet).

Personally I feel great eating low carb and find that the greatly reduced hunger plus good energy makes it something I can live comfortably with (plus delicious food choices - no one is suggesting I eat fat free dairy!). But we're all different, others might go bonkers without bread - I find it pretty easy to live without.

I also don't believe at all that a calorie is a calorie. If you like science and really want to understand how we as a nation made this big unfounded turn to low farm I recommend reading Gary Taubes. If you're a science nerd or a big reader, Good Calories, Bad Calories, and if you don't want as challenging a book he made a simpler version Why We Get Fat.
sarahinparis is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-21-2014, 10:30 AM   #10  
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2014
Posts: 3


This book, by Jonathan Bailor, is very much like Gary Taubes' work.

JohnP, in his definition, "high-quality" food is high protein, "Low-quality" is what he calls starch/sugar (carbs, basically). I think he avoids calling it low carb for obvious reasons.

Re: The calories in/Calories out theory, he makes a pretty compelling case for set point. When people are obese, why do they not continue to gain and gain and gain ad infinitem? I have a friend who is quite obese. But if you saw the amount of food she eats, it is a wonder that she is not 500 pounds. The body does try to maintain a certain weight, whether that weight is low or high.

On other diet boards there is discussion about low carb being difficult to maintain. We are designed to like sweet things, starting with breast milk. It is difficult to shut that off forever.
legg3819 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-21-2014, 05:38 PM   #11  
Which round am I at now?
souvenirdarling's Avatar
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 908

S/C/G: 158/see ticker/140

Height: 5' 5-3/4"


I like low-carb - or rather, moderate carb. Limit sugar to have a consistent blood sugar. Stops cravings and binge-eating and mood problems. Less bloat, seriously less gas. The occasional quality dessert, I allow fruit. I stop being hypoglycemic.

It doesnt always make me lose a ton of weight fast, but its an effective long term way of eating for me. I say try it seriously for a month, letting go of other "diet" ideas like low fat and counting calories.
souvenirdarling is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-21-2014, 05:50 PM   #12  
Starting over sucks.
Radiojane's Avatar
Join Date: Nov 2012
Location: Saskatchewan
Posts: 2,245

S/C/G: 485/445/250

Height: 6'1


Without getting bogged down in books and theories, let me just share my experience. Your mileage of course, may vary.

I lost 100 pounds eating low carb whole foods (vegetables and meat). After the first week of detox I felt fantastic. I was able to go more than 90 days at a stretch without cheating. If I did, it was usually due to a function I couldn't avoid and not wanting to be singled out. Through this time my bloodwork was good, I exercised daily and I slept well. My carbs were never above 50g a day.

After that first 100 pounds, my mind started to mess me up. I felt restricted because eating out was not an option and my boyfriend still insisted on carbs. I decided to try plain calorie counting and carb moderation. My weight loss stopped dead. I upped my calories. Lowered them. I never stopped eating whole foods, but every pound was a colossal struggle. I also found my energy levels suffering.

I went back to low carb and I'm losing again. I've carefully researched and played around with my carb levels to find what I maintain at and what I feel good at. I will be low carb for life.

I believe that over consumption of sugar and simple carbs do mess with hunger signals and glucose. If you've continuously overindulged (and I did), you probably have a lot of damage to undo. However, every body varies, and this might not be the case for you. It takes practice and trial and error to find a plan that works best for you. If you do decide to go low carb, give it two full weeks to get past the "carb flu" withdrawal symptoms. They're tough, and that's where a lot of people give up.
Radiojane is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-21-2014, 06:22 PM   #13  
Senior Member
kaplods's Avatar
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Wausau, WI
Posts: 13,383

S/C/G: SW:394/310/180

Height: 5'6"


I think low-carb eating is considered unsustainable in the long term only because we've been culturally brainwashed to believe that life isn't worth living unless it includes large and frequent amounts of bread, pasta, potatoes, and sweets.

It doesn't help that because carbs are often celebration foods, you risk being labeled and berated as a party pooper if you decline, and subject to carb-pushing as a result.
kaplods is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-21-2014, 06:52 PM   #14  
Senior Member
ReillyJ's Avatar
Join Date: Jun 2012
Location: WA state
Posts: 617

S/C/G: 260/155/155

Height: 5'6"


Originally Posted by Jacqui_D View Post
I am doing a modified Slow Carb Diet, and for 6 days a week, it's low carb, but the 7th day is a cheat day when I can have anything I want. That's how I am able to stick with it without a problem. It's not for everyone though. Some people are triggered by a cheat day. For the plan to work, you absolutely must go back to low carb on the non-cheat days; otherwise, you're just cheating all the time rather than lowering your overall carb intake.
ReillyJ is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-21-2014, 07:31 PM   #15  
Senior Member
vealcalf2000's Avatar
Join Date: Jul 2007
Posts: 513

S/C/G: 251/190/175

Height: 5'10


I think our diet plans of choice are such personal decisions. What works for one doesn't work for another. I think the idea is that most diets encourage eating less and exercising more. The plan you chose should be the one that works best for you.

WW's never worked for me. Way too much freedom of food choices! LOL I was like a kid in a candy store using my points to buy foods that were not so good for me. At the end of the day I was left hungry due to an overabundance of empty calories. Who's fault was that? LOL I take full responsibility.

In the end I had to figure out what worked for me. Low carb fullfilled my needs...I like to feel full and I like the way the balance of proteins and vegetables help me control my blood sugar.

I'm not sure I understand your statement..."Impossible to stick to low carb forever"...are you referring to people who do low carb or just yourself? Most people find they lose their "taste" for carbs and sugars over time. One thing I struggled with though, as many others have too, is maybe getting bored with food choices. I'd find myself in a rut of eating eggs, eggs, eggs, chicken, chicken, chicken. Again that was my own fault. Simply adding a variety of items to my grocery list and simple preparations can save you from food boredom. Also, for anyone who NEEDS bread, there are a ton of good sites out there with good recipes for making breads using flaxseed, coconut flour, etc. as very nice substitutes.

If you were referring to yourself as not being able to low carb forever, then you may need do some more research and figure out if it's truly for you. I"m sorry I don't know anything about the book you are referring to, so I can't offer much in regards to that. Good luck!!!
vealcalf2000 is offline   Reply With Quote

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 10:10 AM.

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites.